Neutral Site Games:
2004 All games at Tate Rink, West Point, New York
2005 Final four at Northford Ice Pavilion, Northford, Connecticut
2006-07 Final four at Hart Center, Worcester, Massachusetts
2008 Final five at Blue Cross Arena, Rochester, New York
All rounds are single game elimination unless otherwise stated. Home team in all capitals.
| American International 4, Army 3 |
Quarterfinals
March 13
| Sacred Heart 3, Connecticut 0 | |
| Canisius 1, Quinnipiac 0 (ot) | |
| Holy Cross 5, American International 0 | |
| Mercyhurst 5, Bentley 4 |
Semifinals
March 14
| Holy Cross 4, Canisius 1 | |
| Sacred Heart 3, Mercyhurst 2 |
Championship
March 20
| Holy Cross 4, Sacred Heart 0 |
| ARMY 5, American International 3 |
Quarterfinals
March 12
| QUINNIPIAC 2, Army 0 | |
| Bentley 4, CANISIUS 2 | |
| MERCYHURST 7, Connecticut 4 | |
| HOLY CROSS 4, Sacred Heart 2 |
Semifinals
March 18
| Quinnipiac 4, Bentley 1 | |
| Mercyhurst 4, Holy Cross 3 (ot) |
Championship
March 19
| Mercyhurst 3, Quinnipiac 2 (ot) |
| HOLY CROSS 3, American International 1 | |
| MERCYHURST 7, Canisius 2 | |
| Connecticut 4, SACRED HEART 1 | |
| BENTLEY 4, Army 3 (ot) |
Semifinals
March 17
| Holy Cross 4, Connecticut 1 | |
| Bentley 3, Mercyhurst 2 (ot) |
Championship
March 18
| Holy Cross 5, Bentley 2 |
| American International 2, CANISIUS 1 |
Quarterfinals
March 10
| SACRED HEART 4, American International 0 | |
| ARMY 6, Bentley 2 | |
| CONNECTICUT 5, Mercyhurst 4 | |
| AIR FORCE 3, Holy Cross 0 |
Semifinals
March 16
| Air Force 5, Sacred Heart 4 (ot) | |
| Army 3, Connecticut 1 |
Championship
March 17
| Air Force 6, Army 1 |
March 7
| SACRED HEART 6, Connecticut 5 | |
| ARMY 4, American International 0 | |
| MERCYHURST 4, Canisius 1 | |
| RIT 5, Holy Cross 4 (ot) | |
| AIR FORCE 9, Bentley 2 |
March 8
| MERCYHURST 2, Canisius 1 (ot) | |
| RIT 5, Holy Cross 4 (ot) | |
| AIR FORCE 3, Bentley 1 | |
| Connecticut 3, SACRED HEART 2 (ot) | |
| ARMY 5, American International 2 |
March 9
| SACRED HEART 4, Connecticut 1 |
Final Five
March 14
| Mercyhurst 4, Sacred Heart 1 |
Semifinals
March 15
| Mercyhurst 4, Army 2 | |
| Air Force 5, RIT 0 |
Championship
March 16
| Air Force 5, Mercyhurst 4 |