| - Bill Wilson, Loyola [Loyola 7, MIT 0 on December 27, 1951]
- Bradley Richardson, Harvard [Harvard 13, Williams 0 on December 28, 1951]
- Fred Hitt, Dartmouth [Dartmouth 4, MIT 0 on December 28, 1951]
- Bob Copp, Brown [Brown 5, Rensselaer 0 on December 28, 1951]
- Bob Fox, Rensselaer [Rensselaer 5, Princeton 0 on January 1, 1954]
- Harry Batchelder, Brown [Brown 6, New Brunswick 0 on January 3, 1958]
- George Gratton, North Dakota [North Dakota 15, Yale 0 on January 1, 1960]
- Gary Bonney, Western Ontario [Western Ontario 9, Middlebury 0 on December 28, 1965]
- Jim Weber, Waterloo [Waterloo 11, Ohio University 0 on December 27, 1968]
- Bill Milner, Providence [Providence 4, Northeastern 0 on December 27, 1975]
- Kevin Constantine, Rensselaer [Rensselaer 8, McGill 0 on December 29, 1977]
- Jim Hrivnak, Merrimack [Merrimack 2, Rensselaer 0 on November 29, 1986]
- Sean Kennedy, Rensselaer [Rensselaer 6, Notre Dame 0 on December 29, 1988]
- Jayme Platt, Lake Superior [Lake Superior 5, Yale 0 on December 29, 1997]
- Joel Laing, Rensselaer [Rensselaer 4, Army 0 on December 29, 1997]
- Mike Johnson and Tim Warner, Massachusetts [Massachusetts 4, Niagara 0 on December 28, 2001]
- Matt Kelly, Wayne State [Wayne State 7, Princeton 0 on December 28, 2002]
- Jordan Alford, Rensselaer [Rensselaer 2, Robert Morris 0 on November 26, 2004]
- Peter Foster, Air Force [Air Force 1, Rensselaer 0 on November 27, 2004]
- Brian Mahoney-Wilson, Lake Superior [Union 0, Lake Superior 0 (ot) on November 27, 2009]
- Keith Kinkaid, Union [Union 0, Lake Superior 0 (ot) on November 27, 2009]
| |
| - Bob Wheeler, Brown (7) [Brown 10, Williams 1 on December 27, 1951]
- Abbie Moore, Rensselaer [Rensselaer 6, Harvard 2 on December 27, 1951]
- Reginald Wood, Harvard [Harvard 13, Williams 0 on December 28, 1951]
- Edward Hubbard, Harvard [Harvard 13, Williams 0 on December 28, 1951]
- Gordie Peterkin, Rensselaer [Rensselaer 5, St. Patrick's 4 on January 1, 1953]
- Frank Chiarelli, Rensselaer [Rensselaer 5, Princeton 4 on January 3, 1953]
- Ambrose Mosco, Rensselaer [Rensselaer 5, Brown 1 on December 30, 1953]
- Ken Flynn, St. Francis Xavier [St. Francis Xavier 8, Brown 1 on January 1, 1954]
- Ken Yackel, Minnesota [Minnesota 10, Princeton 1 on December 31, 1955]
- Michael Lagace, Laval [Michigan Tech. 9, Laval 6 on December 28, 1956]
- Leo Konyk, McGill [McGill 6, Laval 4 on December 29, 1956]
- Ross Hughes, McGill [McGill 6, Laval 4 on December 29, 1956]
- Paul Midghall, Rensselaer [Rensselaer 4, Brown 1 on January 2, 1958]
- Dave Kelley, Brown (4) [Brown 6, New Brunswick 0 on January 3, 1958]
- John McBride, Princeton [Michigan State 7, Princeton 4 on January 2, 1959]
- Ray Belasky, Rensselaer [Rensselaer 8, Brown 1 on January 2, 1959]
- Art Miller, North Dakota (4) [North Dakota 15, Yale 0 on January 1, 1960]
- Reg Morelli, North Dakota [North Dakota 15, Yale 0 on January 1, 1960]
- Bill Colpitts, North Dakota [North Dakota 15, Yale 0 on January 1, 1960]
- Roger Hamel, Montreal [Montreal 4, Rensselaer 3 on January 1, 1960]
- Trevor Kaye, Rensselaer [Rensselaer 5, Harvard 3 on December 28, 1960]
- Ken Astill, Rensselaer [Rensselaer 11, Princeton 3 on December 29, 1960]
- Jim Josephson, Rensselaer (4) [Rensselaer 6, McGill 3 on December 28, 1961]
- Gordon Berenson, Michigan (4) [Michigan 10, McGill 1 on December 29, 1961]
- Gordon Berenson, Michigan (4) [Michigan 8, Rensselaer 3 on December 30, 1961]
- Bill Mahoney, McMaster (4) [McMaster 8, Rensselaer 3 on December 27, 1962]
- Jerry Knightley, Rensselaer [Rensselaer 5, Loyola 3 on January 3, 1964]
- Mike Tok, Minnesota-Duluth [Minnesota-Duluth 10, McGill 1 on December 29, 1964]
- Owen Rogers, Minnesota-Duluth [Minnesota-Duluth 10, McGill 1 on December 29, 1964]
- Jerry Knightley, Rensselaer [Rensselaer 8, Colgate 6 on December 29, 1964]
- John Hospodar, Western Ontario (5) [Western Ontario 11, Rensselaer 1 on December 30, 1965]
- Bob Baird, Michigan [Michigan 13, New Brunswick 3 on December 28, 1966]
- Ron Ullyot, Michigan [Michigan 13, New Brunswick 3 on December 28, 1966]
- Tom Huntzicker, Colgate [Colgate 6, Rensselaer 1 on December 28, 1966]
- Rich Scammell, Rensselaer [Rensselaer 5, New Brunswick 2 on December 29, 1966]
- Doug Stay, Colgate [Colgate 6, New Brunswick 3 on December 30, 1966]
- Graeme Taylor, McMaster [McMaster 10, Rensselaer 6 on December 29, 1967]
- Ken Laidlaw, Waterloo (4) [Waterloo 11, Ohio University 0 on December 27, 1968]
- Bob Reade, Waterloo [Waterloo 11, Ohio University 0 on December 27, 1968]
- Ken Laidlaw, Waterloo (4) [Waterloo 9, Army 2 on December 28, 1968]
- Dave Merhar, Army [Army 9, Ohio University 4 on December 29, 1968]
- John Ahlbrecht, Army [Army 9, Ohio University 4 on December 29, 1968]
- Dave Rudge, Waterloo [Waterloo 8, Rensselaer 5 on December 29, 1968]
- Doug Hearns, Rensselaer [Rensselaer 8, Northeastern 2 on January 2, 1971]
- Gary Winchester, Wisconsin (4) [Wisconsin 14, Northeastern 3 on January 3, 1971]
- Duane LaShomb, Clarkson [Clarkson 9, New Brunswick 3 on December 28, 1971]
- Mike Conroy, Clarkson [Clarkson 8, Ohio University 2 on December 29, 1971]
- Frank Hubley, New Brunswick [Ohio University 5, New Brunswick 4 on December 30, 1971]
- Tom Milani, Minnesota-Duluth [Minnesota-Duluth 9, Carleton 2 on December 29, 1972]
- Don Hearns, Rensselaer [Rensselaer 5, Ohio State 5 on December 27, 1973]
- Pat Hahn, Rensselaer (4) [Rensselaer 5, Northeastern 2 on December 28, 1975]
- Dave Sherlock, Northeastern [Princeton 6, Northeastern 6 on December 29, 1975]
- Bill Blackwood, Clarkson [Clarkson 12, Pennsylvania 3 on December 29, 1976]
- Dino Serra, Rensselaer [Rensselaer 9, Yale 7 on December 29, 1976]
- Gary Conn, Maine [Maine 12, Holy Cross 2 on December 27, 1980]
- Marty Dallman, Rensselaer [Rensselaer 11, Vasby 3 on December 27, 1980]
- Don Vaughan, St. Lawrence (4) [St. Lawrence 10, Brown 2 on December 30, 1981]
- Steve Arnold, Lowell [Rensselaer 8, Lowell 6 on December 30, 1982]
- George Servinis, Rensselaer [Rensselaer 8, Lowell 6 on December 30, 1982]
- John Carter, Rensselaer [Rensselaer 5, Yale 4 on December 30, 1983]
- Darren Boyko, Toronto [Toronto 6, Ferris State 3 on December 28, 1984]
- Ritchie Herbert, RIT [RIT 10, Alaska-Anchorage 5 on November 30, 1985]
- Richard Pion, Merrimack [Ferris State 5, Merrimack 4 on November 28, 1986]
- Jeff Crossley, Alaska-Fairbanks [Ferris State 5, Alaska-Fairbanks 4 (ot) on November 29, 1986]
- Bruce Coles, Rensselaer [Rensselaer 12, Union 4 on December 28, 1990]
- Dalton Menhall, Union [Rensselaer 12, Union 4 on December 28, 1990]
- Wayne Clarke, Rensselaer [Rensselaer 12, Mount Allison 1 on December 29, 1993]
- Jeff Brick, Rensselaer [Rensselaer 11, Massachusetts-Lowell 3 on December 30, 1993]
- Tim Lovell, Maine [Maine 5, Miami 3 on December 29, 1994]
- Eric Healey, Rensselaer (4) [Rensselaer 9, Massachusetts 5 on December 27, 1996]
- Eric Healey, Rensselaer [Rensselaer 4, Army 0 on December 29, 1997]
- Rob Bumbaco, Niagara [Niagara 7, Quinnipiac 6 on December 29, 2001]
- Andrei Uryadov, Rensselaer [Rensselaer 5, Ohio State 5 (ot) on November 25, 2006]
| |