| All-WCHA Teams | |
| NOTE: No league play in 1958-59. | |
| | | | | | | | |
| |
1951-52 |
| First Team | Second Team | |
| G | Ken Kinsley, Colorado College | Willard Ikola, Michigan | | |
| D | Don Burgess, Denver | Joe deBastiani, Michigan Tech. | | |
| D | Eddie Miller, Denver | Elwood Shell, North Dakota | | |
| F | Tony Frasca, Colorado College | John Mayasich, Minnesota | | |
| F | Ron Hartwell, Colorado College | John McKennell, Michigan | | |
| F | Omer Brandt, Colorado College | Bill Abbott, Denver | | |
| |
| |
1952-53 |
| First Team | Second Team | |
| G | Jim Mattson, Minnesota | Willard Ikola, Michigan | | |
| D | Tom Wegleitner, Minnesota | Alex MacLellan, Michigan | | |
| D | Eddie Miller, Denver | Elwood Shell, North Dakota | | |
| F | Ben Cherski, North Dakota | Gene Campbell, Minnesota | | |
| F | Dick Dougherty, Minnesota | John Matchefts, Michigan | | |
| F | John Mayasich, Minnesota | Bill Abbott, Denver | | |
| F | | Joe deBastiani, Michigan Tech. | | |
| |
| |
1953-54 |
| First Team | Second Team | |
| G | Jim Mattson, Minnesota | Gerald Schultz, North Dakota | | |
| D | Ken Yackel, Minnesota | Phil Hilton, Colorado College | | |
| D | Jim Haas, Michigan | Bill Abbott, Denver | | |
| F | John Mayasich, Minnesota | Doug Mullen, Michigan | | |
| F | Dick Dougherty, Minnesota | George Chin, Michigan | | |
| F | Ben Cherski, North Dakota | Bill MacFarland, Michigan | | |
| F | | Jack Smith, Denver | | |
| |
| |
1954-55 |
| First Team | Second Team | |
| G | Bob McManus, Michigan Tech. | Jeff Simus, Colorado College | | |
| D | Ken Yackel, Minnesota | Doug Silverberg, Colorado College | | |
| D | Phil Hilton, Colorado College | Bob Schiller, Michigan | | |
| D | | Bill Abbott, Denver | | |
| F | John Mayasich, Minnesota | Jack McManus, Michigan Tech. | | |
| F | Bill Reichart, North Dakota | Bunt Hubchik, Colorado College | | |
| F | Clare Smith, Colorado College | Bill MacFarland, Michigan | | |
| F | | Jack Smith, Denver | | |
| |
| |
1955-56 |
| First Team | Second Team | |
| G | Lorne Howes, Michigan | Bob McManus, Michigan Tech. | | |
| D | Ken Yackel, Minnesota | Ed Zemrau, Denver | | |
| D | Doug Silverberg, Colorado College | Bob Pitts, Michigan | | |
| F | Bill MacFarland, Michigan | John Andrews, Colorado College | | |
| F | Bill Reichart, North Dakota | Tom Rendall, Michigan | | |
| F | Jack McManus, Michigan Tech. | Clare Smith, Colorado College | | |
| |
| |
1956-57 |
| First Team | Second Team | |
| G | Jack McCartan, Minnesota | Tom Yurkovich, North Dakota | | |
| D | Bill Steenson, North Dakota | Bob Pitts, Michigan | | |
| D | Don Wishart, Colorado College | Bob Schiller, Michigan | | |
| F | Bill Hay, Colorado College | Jack McManus, Michigan Tech. | | |
| F | Bill Reichart, North Dakota | Tom Rendall, Michigan | | |
| F | Bob McCusker, Colorado College | Tom Kennedy, Michigan Tech. | | |
| |
| |
1957-58 |
| First Team | Second Team | |
| G | Jack McCartan, Minnesota | Joe Selinger, Michigan State | | |
| D | Bill Steenson, North Dakota | Bob Watt, Michigan | | |
| D | Ed Zemrau, Denver | Mike Pearson, Minnesota | | |
| F | Bill Hay, Colorado College | Dick Burg, Minnesota | | |
| F | Ike Scott, Colorado College | Jim Ridley, North Dakota | | |
| F | Bob McCusker, Colorado College | Murray Massier, Denver | | |
| |
| |
1959-60 |
| First Team | Second Team | |
| G | George Kirkwood, Denver | George Cuculick, Michigan Tech. | | |
| D | Marty Howe, Denver | Guy LaFrance, North Dakota | | |
| D | Henry Akervall, Michigan Tech. | George Konik, Denver | | |
| F | Reg Morelli, North Dakota | Gerald Fabbro, Michigan Tech. | | |
| F | Bill Masterton, Denver | John MacMillan, Denver | | |
| F | John Kosiancic, Michigan Tech. | Paul Coppo, Michigan Tech. | | |
| |
| |
1960-61 |
| First Team | Second Team | |
| G | George Kirkwood, Denver | Bill Rowe, Michigan Tech. | | |
| D | Marty Howe, Denver | John Palenstein, Michigan | | |
| D | George Konik, Denver | Henry Akervall, Michigan Tech. | | |
| F | Gordon Berenson, Michigan | Lou Angotti, Michigan Tech. | | |
| F | Bill Masterton, Denver | Bill Colpitts, North Dakota | | |
| F | Jerry Walker, Denver | Jerry Sullivan, Michigan Tech. | | |
| |
| |
1961-62 |
| First Team | Second Team | |
| G | Garry Bauman, Michigan Tech. | Bob Gray, Michigan | | |
| D | Henry Akervall, Michigan Tech. | Elov Seger, Michigan Tech. | | |
| D | Jack Wilson, Denver | Don Rodgers, Michigan | | |
| F | Gordon Berenson, Michigan | Gene Rebellato, Michigan Tech. | | |
| F | Jerry Sullivan, Michigan Tech. | Trent Beatty, Denver | | |
| F | Lou Angotti, Michigan Tech. | Gordon Wilkie, Michigan | | |
| |
| |
1962-63 |
| First Team | Second Team | |
| G | Garry Bauman, Michigan Tech. | Joe Lech, North Dakota | | |
| D | Louis Nanne, Minnesota | Gary Begg, Michigan Tech. | | |
| D | Don Ross, North Dakota | Jack Wilson, Denver | | |
| F | Bill Staub, Denver | Dominic Fragomeni, Denver | | |
| F | Dave Merrifield, North Dakota | John Ivanitz, Michigan Tech. | | |
| F | Gary Butler, Michigan | Al McLean, North Dakota | | |
| F | George Hill, Michigan Tech. | | | |
| |
| |
1963-64 |
| First Team | Second Team | |
| G | Garry Bauman, Michigan Tech. | Buddy Blom, Denver | | |
| D | Norm Wimmer, Michigan Tech. | Wayne Smith, Denver | | |
| D | Tom Polonic, Michigan | Jim Kenning, Denver | | |
| D | | Carl Lackey, Michigan State | | |
| F | Bill Staub, Denver | Craig Falkman, Minnesota | | |
| F | Gordon Wilkie, Michigan | Scott Watson, Michigan Tech. | | |
| F | Gary Butler, Michigan | George Hill, Michigan Tech. | | |
| F | John Simus, Colorado College | | | |
| |
| |
1964-65 |
| First Team | Second Team | |
| G | Tony Esposito, Michigan Tech. | Joe Lech, North Dakota | | |
| D | Don Ross, North Dakota | Dennis Huculak, Michigan Tech. | | |
| D | Wayne Smith, Denver | Tom Polonic, Michigan | | |
| F | Gerry Kell, North Dakota | Gary Milroy, Michigan Tech. | | |
| F | Mel Wakabayashi, Michigan | Doug Roberts, Michigan State | | |
| F | Doug Woog, Minnesota | Dennis Hextall, North Dakota | | |
| |
| |
1965-66 |
| First Team | Second Team | |
| G | Tony Esposito, Michigan Tech. | John Lothrop, Minnesota | | |
| D | Wayne Smith, Denver | Dennis Huculak, Michigan Tech. | | |
| D | Bruce Riutta, Michigan Tech. | Bob Hill, Minnesota-Duluth | | |
| F | Doug Volmar, Michigan State | Wayne Weller, Michigan Tech. | | |
| F | Terry Casey, North Dakota | Mel Wakabayashi, Michigan | | |
| F | Dennis Hextall, North Dakota | Gary Gambucci, Minnesota | | |
| |
| |
1966-67 |
| First Team | Second Team | |
| G | Tony Esposito, Michigan Tech. | Rick Best, Michigan Tech. | | |
| D | Keith Magnuson, Denver | Paul Domm, Michigan | | |
| D | Jerry Lafond, North Dakota | Bruce Riutta, Michigan Tech. | | |
| F | Keith Christiansen, Minnesota-Duluth | Bob Toothill, Michigan Tech. | | |
| F | Jim Wiste, Denver | Gary Milroy, Michigan Tech. | | |
| F | Tom Mikkola, Michigan State | Bob Lindberg, Colorado College | | |
| |
| |
1967-68 |
| First Team | Second Team | |
| G | Mike Curran, North Dakota | Gerry Powers, Denver | | |
| D | Keith Magnuson, Denver | Dick Paradise, Minnesota | | |
| D | Terry Abram, North Dakota | Dick Sieradzki, Michigan Tech. | | |
| F | Bob Munro, North Dakota | Bill Klatt, Minnesota | | |
| F | Jim Wiste, Denver | Cliff Koroll, Denver | | |
| F | Gary Gambucci, Minnesota | Al Karlander, Michigan Tech. | | |
| |
| |
1968-69 |
| First Team | Second Team | |
| G | Murray McLachlan, Minnesota | Gerry Powers, Denver | | |
| D | Keith Magnuson, Denver | Paul Domm, Michigan | | |
| D | Terry Abram, North Dakota | John Marks, North Dakota | | |
| F | George Morrison, Denver | Dave Kartio, North Dakota | | |
| F | Bob Munro, North Dakota | Tom Miller, Denver | | |
| F | Al Karlander, Michigan Tech. | Bob Collyard, Colorado College | | |
| |
| |
1969-70 |
| First Team | Second Team | |
| G | Murray McLachlan, Minnesota | Wayne Thomas, Wisconsin | | |
| D | John Marks, North Dakota | John Jagger, Wisconsin | | |
| D | Ron Busniuk, Minnesota-Duluth | Wally Olds, Minnesota | | |
| F | George Morrison, Denver | Bernie Gagnon, Michigan | | |
| F | Murray Keogan, Minnesota-Duluth | Murray Heatley, Wisconsin | | |
| F | Bob Collyard, Colorado College | Tom Gilmore, Denver | | |
| |
| |
1970-71 |
| First Team | Second Team | |
| G | Morris Trewin, Michigan Tech. | Glenn Resch, Minnesota-Duluth | | |
| D | Mike Christie, Denver | John Jagger, Wisconsin | | |
| D | Rob Murray, Michigan Tech. | Wally Olds, Minnesota | | |
| F | Walt Ledingham, Minnesota-Duluth | Murray Heatley, Wisconsin | | |
| F | Don Thompson, Michigan State | Vic Venasky, Denver | | |
| F | Bob Collyard, Colorado College | Mike Usitalo, Michigan Tech. | | |
| |
| |
1971-72 |
| First Team | Second Team | |
| G | Jim Watt, Michigan State | Jim Makey, Wisconsin | | |
| D | Alan Hangsleben, North Dakota | Bob Boyd, Michigan State | | |
| D | Bob Winograd, Colorado College | Rick Wilson, North Dakota | | |
| F | Jim Cahoon, North Dakota | Walt Ledingham, Minnesota-Duluth | | |
| F | Doug Palazzari, Colorado College | Bernie Gagnon, Michigan | | |
| F | Tom Peluso, Denver | Don Thompson, Michigan State | | |
| |
| |
1972-73 |
| First Team | Second Team | |
| G | Ron Grahame, Denver | Jim Makey, Wisconsin | | |
| D | Bob Boyd, Michigan State | Bill Nyrop, Notre Dame | | |
| D | Bruce Affleck, Denver | Jim Nahrgang, Michigan Tech. | | |
| F | Rob Palmer, Denver | Ian Williams, Notre Dame | | |
| F | Eddie Bumbacco, Notre Dame | Norm Cherrey, Wisconsin | | |
| F | Peter McNab, Denver | Pat Boutette, Minnesota-Duluth | | |
| |
| |
1973-74 |
| First Team | Second Team | |
| G | Brad Shelstad, Minnesota | Rick Quance, Michigan Tech. | | |
| D | Jim Nahrgang, Michigan Tech. | Gord McDonald, Minnesota-Duluth | | |
| D | Norm Barnes, Michigan State | Bruce Affleck, Denver | | |
| F | Doug Palazzari, Colorado College | Lorne Stamler, Michigan Tech. | | |
| F | Steve Colp, Michigan State | Tom Ross, Michigan State | | |
| F | Mike Zuke, Michigan Tech. | Ray DeLorenzi, Notre Dame | | |
| |
| |
1974-75 |
| First Team | Second Team | |
| G | Jim Warden, Michigan Tech. | Eddie Mio, Colorado College | | |
| D | Brian Engblom, Wisconsin | Bob Lorimer, Michigan Tech. | | |
| D | Gord McDonald, Minnesota-Duluth | Les Auge, Minnesota | | |
| F | Tom Ross, Michigan State | Mike Zuke, Michigan Tech. | | |
| F | Bob D'Alvise, Michigan Tech. | Jim Warner, Colorado College | | |
| F | Mike Polich, Minnesota | Tom Milani, Minnesota-Duluth | | |
| |
| |
1975-76 |
| First Team | Second Team | |
| G | Eddie Mio, Colorado College | Robbie Moore, Michigan | | |
| D | Jack Brownschidle, Notre Dame | Dave Langevin, Minnesota-Duluth | | |
| D | Reed Larson, Minnesota | Craig Norwich, Wisconsin | | |
| F | Tom Ross, Michigan State | Dave Debol, Michigan | | |
| F | George Lyle, Michigan Tech. | Tom Milani, Minnesota-Duluth | | |
| F | Mike Zuke, Michigan Tech. | Steve Colp, Michigan State | | |
| |
| |
1976-77 |
| First Team | Second Team | |
| G | Julian Baretta, Wisconsin | John Peterson, Notre Dame | | |
| D | Jack Brownschidle, Notre Dame | Greg Woods, Denver | | |
| D | Craig Norwich, Wisconsin | John Taft, Wisconsin | | |
| F | Brian Walsh, Notre Dame | Dan Lempe, Minnesota-Duluth | | |
| F | Dave Debol, Michigan | Roger Lamoureux, North Dakota | | |
| F | Kris Manery, Michigan | Mike Eaves, Wisconsin | | |
| |
| |
1977-78 |
| First Team | Second Team | |
| G | Ernie Glanville, Denver | Julian Baretta, Wisconsin | | |
| D | Curt Giles, Minnesota-Duluth | Greg Woods, Denver | | |
| D | Bill Himmelright, North Dakota | Lex Hudson, Denver | | |
| F | Doug Berry, Denver | Greg Whyte, Colorado College | | |
| F | Mark Johnson, Wisconsin | Steve Christoff, Minnesota | | |
| F | Mike Eaves, Wisconsin | Dave Delich, Colorado College | | |
| F | | Perry Schnarr, Denver | | |
| |
| |
1978-79 |
| First Team | Second Team | |
| G | Bob Iwabuchi, North Dakota | John Rockwell, Michigan Tech. | | |
| D | Curt Giles, Minnesota-Duluth | Bob Suter, Wisconsin | | |
| D | Bill Baker, Minnesota | Dave Feamster, Colorado College | | |
| F | Mark Pavelich, Minnesota-Duluth | Gord Salt, Michigan Tech. | | |
| F | Mark Johnson, Wisconsin | Dave Delich, Colorado College | | |
| F | Kevin Maxwell, North Dakota | Steve Christoff, Minnesota | | |
| |
| |
1979-80 |
| First Team | Second Team | |
| G | Roy Schultz, Wisconsin | Tom Frame, Colorado College | | |
| D | Dave Feamster, Colorado College | Theran Welsh, Wisconsin | | |
| D | Howard Walker, North Dakota | Marc Chorney, North Dakota | | |
| F | Tim Harrer, Minnesota | Doug Smail, North Dakota | | |
| F | Mark Taylor, North Dakota | Murray Eaves, Michigan | | |
| F | Greg Meredith, Notre Dame | Dan Lempe, Minnesota-Duluth | | |
| |
| |
1980-81 |
| First Team | Second Team | |
| G | Ron Scott, Michigan State | Paul Fricker, Michigan | | |
| D | Marc Chorney, North Dakota | John Blum, Michigan | | |
| D | Tim Watters, Michigan Tech. | Theran Welsh, Wisconsin | | |
| F | Steve Ulseth, Minnesota | Ken Berry, Denver | | |
| F | Neal Broten, Minnesota | Bruce Aikens, Colorado College | | |
| F | Aaron Broten, Minnesota | Troy Murray, North Dakota | | |
| |
| |
1981-82 |
| First Team | Second Team | |
| G | Jon Casey, North Dakota | Marc Behrend, Wisconsin | | |
| D | Doug Lidster, Colorado College | James Patrick, North Dakota | | |
| D | Bruce Driver, Wisconsin | Craig Ludwig, North Dakota | | |
| F | Ed Beers, Denver | Bryan Erickson, Minnesota | | |
| F | Phil Sykes, North Dakota | Gregg Moore, Minnesota-Duluth | | |
| F | John Newberry, Wisconsin | Troy Murray, North Dakota | | |
| |
| |
1982-83 |
| First Team | Second Team | |
| G | Bob Mason, Minnesota-Duluth | Jon Casey, North Dakota | | |
| D | James Patrick, North Dakota | Bruce Driver, Wisconsin | | |
| D | Doug Lidster, Colorado College | Chris Chelios, Wisconsin | | |
| F | Scott Bjugstad, Minnesota | Paul Houck, Wisconsin | | |
| F | Bryan Erickson, Minnesota | Dave Tippett, North Dakota | | |
| F | Pat Flatley, Wisconsin | Gregg Moore, Minnesota-Duluth | | |
| |
| |
1983-84 |
| First Team | Second Team | |
| G | Jon Casey, North Dakota | Rick Kosti, Minnesota-Duluth | | |
| D | Tom Kurvers, Minnesota-Duluth | Tony Kellin, Minnesota | | |
| D | Jim Leavins, Denver | Rick Zombo, North Dakota | | |
| D | | Norm Maciver, Minnesota-Duluth | | |
| F | Bill Watson, Minnesota-Duluth | Tom Herzig, Minnesota-Duluth | | |
| F | Dan Brennan, North Dakota | Bob Lakso, Minnesota-Duluth | | |
| F | Tom Rothstein, Minnesota | Matt Christensen, Minnesota-Duluth | | |
| |
| |
1984-85 |
| First Team | Second Team | |
| G | Rick Kosti, Minnesota-Duluth | John Blue, Minnesota | | |
| D | Tim Thomas, Wisconsin | Rob Doyle, Colorado College | | |
| D | Norm Maciver, Minnesota-Duluth | Doug Clarke, Colorado College | | |
| F | Bill Watson, Minnesota-Duluth | Matt Christensen, Minnesota-Duluth | | |
| F | Pat Micheletti, Minnesota | Corey Millen, Minnesota | | |
| F | Jim Archibald, North Dakota | Tony Granato, Wisconsin | | |
| |
| |
1985-86 |
| First Team | Second Team | |
| G | John Blue, Minnesota | Tom Allen, Denver | | |
| D | Norm Maciver, Minnesota-Duluth | Marty Wiitala, Wisconsin | | |
| D | Scott Sandelin, North Dakota | Rob Doyle, Colorado College | | |
| F | Dallas Gaume, Denver | Corey Millen, Minnesota | | |
| F | Gary Emmons, Northern Michigan | Pat Micheletti, Minnesota | | |
| F | Brett Hull, Minnesota-Duluth | Dwight Mathiasen, Denver | | |
| |
| |
1986-87 |
| First Team | Second Team | |
| G | Ed Belfour, North Dakota | Mike Richter, Wisconsin | | |
| D | Rob Doyle, Colorado College | Todd Richards, Minnesota | | |
| D | Ian Kidd, North Dakota | Guy Gosselin, Minnesota-Duluth | | |
| F | Tony Hrkac, North Dakota | Rick Boh, Colorado College | | |
| F | Bob Joyce, North Dakota | Paul Ranheim, Wisconsin | | |
| F | Gary Emmons, Northern Michigan | Corey Millen, Minnesota | | |
| F | | Tony Granato, Wisconsin | | |
| |
| |
1987-88 |
| First Team | Second Team | |
| G | Robb Stauber, Minnesota | Dean Anderson, Wisconsin | | |
| D | Mike DeAngelis, Minnesota-Duluth | Todd Richards, Minnesota | | |
| D | Randy Skarda, Minnesota | Paul Stanton, Wisconsin | | |
| F | Phil Berger, Northern Michigan | Steve Tuttle, Wisconsin | | |
| F | Paul Ranheim, Wisconsin | John Archibald, Michigan Tech. | | |
| F | Steve Johnson, North Dakota | Daryn McBride, Denver | | |
| |
| |
1988-89 |
| First Team | Second Team | |
| G | Curtis Joseph, Wisconsin | Robb Stauber, Minnesota | | |
| D | Paul Stanton, Wisconsin | Todd Richards, Minnesota | | |
| D | Darryl Olsen, Northern Michigan | Russ Parent, North Dakota | | |
| F | Daryn McBride, Denver | Dave Snuggerud, Minnesota | | |
| F | Shawn Harrison, Michigan Tech. | John Byce, Wisconsin | | |
| F | Tom Chorske, Minnesota | Phil Berger, Northern Michigan | | |
| |
| |
1989-90 |
| First Team | Second Team | |
| G | Chad Erickson, Minnesota-Duluth | Duane Derksen, Wisconsin | | |
| D | Kip Noble, Michigan Tech. | Sean Hill, Wisconsin | | |
| D | Russ Parent, North Dakota | Jason Herter, North Dakota | | |
| F | Peter Hankinson, Minnesota | John Byce, Wisconsin | | |
| F | Gary Shuchuk, Wisconsin | Lee Davidson, North Dakota | | |
| F | Dave Shields, Denver | Eric Murano, Denver | | |
| |
| |
1990-91 |
| First Team | Second Team | |
| G | Bill Pye, Northern Michigan | Duane Derksen, Wisconsin | | |
| D | Bret Hedican, St. Cloud State | Jason Herter, North Dakota | | |
| D | Brad Werenka, Northern Michigan | Sean Hill, Wisconsin | | |
| F | Russ Romaniuk, North Dakota | Larry Olimb, Minnesota | | |
| F | Greg Johnson, North Dakota | Kelly Hurd, Michigan Tech. | | |
| F | Scott Beattie, Northern Michigan | Dixon Ward, North Dakota | | |
| |
| |
1991-92 |
| First Team | Second Team | |
| G | Duane Derksen, Wisconsin | Jeff Stolp, Minnesota | | |
| D | Greg Andrusak, Minnesota-Duluth | Travis Richards, Minnesota | | |
| D | Chris Hynnes, Colorado College | Doug Zmolek, Minnesota | | |
| F | Greg Johnson, North Dakota | Dixon Ward, North Dakota | | |
| F | Larry Olimb, Minnesota | Derek Plante, Minnesota-Duluth | | |
| F | Dallas Drake, Northern Michigan | Jim Hiller, Northern Michigan | | |
| |
| |
1992-93 |
| First Team | Second Team | |
| G | Jamie Ram, Michigan Tech. | Jim Carey, Wisconsin | | |
| D | Barry Richter, Wisconsin | Jon Rohloff, Minnesota-Duluth | | |
| D | Brett Hauer, Minnesota-Duluth | Travis Richards, Minnesota | | |
| F | Fred Knipscheer, St. Cloud State | Joe Frederick, Northern Michigan | | |
| F | Greg Johnson, North Dakota | John Young, Michigan Tech. | | |
| F | Derek Plante, Minnesota-Duluth | Chris Marinucci, Minnesota-Duluth | | |
| |
| |
1993-94 |
| First Team | Second Team | |
| G | Jamie Ram, Michigan Tech. | Lee Schill, Alaska-Anchorage | | |
| D | Chris McAlpine, Minnesota | Kelly Hultgren, St. Cloud State | | |
| D | Shawn Reid, Colorado College | Kent Fearns, Colorado College | | |
| F | Jay McNeill, Colorado College | Mike Harding, Northern Michigan | | |
| F | Kelly Fairchild, Wisconsin | Jeff Nielsen, Minnesota | | |
| F | Chris Marinucci, Minnesota-Duluth | Andrew Shier, Wisconsin | | |
| |
| |
1994-95 |
| First Team | Second Team | |
| G | Ryan Bach, Colorado College | Sinuhe Wallinheimo, Denver | | |
| D | Nick Naumenko, North Dakota | Kent Fearns, Colorado College | | |
| D | Brian Rafalski, Wisconsin | Kelly Hultgren, St. Cloud State | | |
| F | Greg Hadden, Northern Michigan | Brad Federenko, Minnesota-Duluth | | |
| F | Jay McNeill, Colorado College | Peter Geronazzo, Colorado College | | |
| F | Brian Bonin, Minnesota | Colin Schmidt, Colorado College | | |
| |
| |
1995-96 |
| First Team | Second Team | Third Team | |
| G | Ryan Bach, Colorado College | Judd Lambert, Colorado College | Teras Lendzyk, Minnesota-Duluth | |
| D | Mike Crowley, Minnesota | Scott Swanson, Colorado College | Taj Melson, St. Cloud State | |
| D | Nick Naumenko, North Dakota | Dan Trebil, Minnesota | Eric Rud, Colorado College | |
| F | Brian Bonin, Minnesota | Brian Swanson, Colorado College | Jay McNeill, Colorado College | |
| F | Peter Geronozzo, Colorado College | Colin Schmidt, Colorado College | David Vallieres, Alaska-Anchorage | |
| F | Teeder Wynne, North Dakota | Antti Laaksonen, Denver | Mike Peluso, Minnesota-Duluth | |
| |
| |
1996-97 |
| First Team | Second Team | Third Team | |
| G | Steve DeBus, Minnesota | Kirk Daubenspeck, Wisconsin | Jim Mullin, Denver | |
| D | Mike Crowley, Minnesota | Eric Rud, Colorado College | Dane Litke, North Dakota | |
| D | Curtis Murphy, North Dakota | Rick Mrozik, Minnesota-Duluth | Calvin Elfring, Colorado College | |
| F | Brian Swanson, Colorado College | Dave Paradise, St. Cloud State | Sacha Molin, St. Cloud State | |
| F | Jason Blake, North Dakota | Matt Cullen, St. Cloud State | Ryan Kraft, Minnesota | |
| F | David Hoogsteen, North Dakota | Mike Peluso, Minnesota-Duluth | Andre Savage, Michigan Tech. | |
| |
| |
1997-98 |
| First Team | Second Team | Third Team | |
| G | Karl Goehring, North Dakota | Brian Leitza, St. Cloud State | Doug Teskey, Alaska-Anchorage | |
| D | Craig Anderson, Wisconsin | Calvin Elfring, Colorado College | Josh DeWolf, St. Cloud State | |
| D | Curtis Murphy, North Dakota | Andy Sutton, Michigan Tech. | Scott Swanson, Colorado College | |
| F | Brian Swanson, Colorado College | Steve Reinprecht, Wisconsin | Mike Peluso, Minnesota-Duluth | |
| F | Jason Blake, North Dakota | Reggie Berg, Minnesota | Wyatt Smith, Minnesota | |
| F | Andre Savage, Michigan Tech. | David Hoogsteen, North Dakota | Paul Comrie, Denver | |
| |
| |
1998-99 |
| First Team | Second Team | Third Team | |
| G | Gregg Naumenko, Alaska-Anchorage | Karl Goehring, North Dakota | Graham Melanson, Wisconsin | |
| D | Brad Williamson, North Dakota | Dan Peters, Colorado College | Jordan Leopold, Minnesota | |
| D | Scott Swanson, Colorado College | Trevor Hammer, North Dakota | Jeff Dessner, Wisconsin | |
| F | Brian Swanson, Colorado College | Jay Panzer, North Dakota | Wyatt Smith, Minnesota | |
| F | Jason Blake, North Dakota | Darren Clark, Colorado College | James Patterson, Denver | |
| F | Paul Comrie, Denver | Jeff Panzer, North Dakota | Lee Goren, North Dakota | |
| |
| |
1999-00 |
| First Team | Second Team | Third Team | |
| G | Karl Goehring, North Dakota | Scott Meyer, St. Cloud State | Graham Melanson, Wisconsin | |
| D | Mike Pudlick, St. Cloud State | Jordan Leopold, Minnesota | Alex Brooks, Wisconsin | |
| D | Jeff Dessner, Wisconsin | Dylan Mills, Minnesota | Paul Manning, Colorado College | |
| F | Dany Heatley, Wisconsin | Tyler Arnason, St. Cloud State | Aaron Fox, Minnesota State | |
| F | Jeff Panzer, North Dakota | John Pohl, Minnesota | Jason Ulmer, North Dakota | |
| F | Steve Reinprecht, Wisconsin | Lee Goren, North Dakota | Erik Westrum, Minnesota | |
| |
| |
2000-01 |
| First Team | Second Team | Third Team | |
| G | Scott Meyer, St. Cloud State | Wade Dubielewicz, Denver | Adam Hauser, Minnesota | |
| D | Travis Roche, North Dakota | Duvie Westcott, St. Cloud State | Ben Christopherson, Minnesota State | |
| D | Jordan Leopold, Minnesota | Paul Manning, Colorado College | Tom Preissing, Colorado College | |
| F | Jeff Panzer, North Dakota | Erik Westrum, Minnesota | Peter Sejna, Colorado College | |
| F | Bryan Lundbohm, North Dakota | Dany Heatley, Wisconsin | Mark Hartigan, St. Cloud State | |
| F | Mark Cullen, Colorado College | Ryan Bayda, North Dakota | Brandon Sampair, St. Cloud State | |
| |
| |
2001-02 |
| First Team | Second Team | Third Team | |
| G | Wade Dubielewicz, Denver | Dean Weasler, St. Cloud State | Adam Berkhoel, Denver | |
| D | Jordan Leopold, Minnesota | Matt Shasby, Alaska-Anchorage | Tom Preissing, Colorado College | |
| D | Andy Reierson, Minnesota-Duluth | Paul Martin, Minnesota | Aaron MacKenzie, Denver | |
| F | Mark Hartigan, St. Cloud State | Ryan Bayda, North Dakota | Jeff Taffe, Minnesota | |
| F | John Pohl, Minnesota | Nate DiCasmirro, St. Cloud State | Connor James, Denver | |
| F | Mark Cullen, Colorado College | Judd Medak, Minnesota-Duluth | Peter Sejna, Colorado College | |
| |
| |
2002-03 |
| First Team | Second Team | Third Team | |
| G | Curtis McElhinney, Colorado College | Wade Dubielewicz, Denver | Isaac Reichmuth, Minnesota-Duluth | |
| D | Tom Preissing, Colorado College | Paul Martin, Minnesota | Andy Schneider, North Dakota | |
| D | Aaron MacKenzie, Denver | Keith Ballard, Minnesota | David Hale, North Dakota | |
| F | Peter Sejna, Colorado College | Noah Clarke, Colorado College | Zach Parise, North Dakota | |
| F | Shane Joseph, Minnesota State | Thomas Vanek, Minnesota | Kevin Doell, Denver | |
| F | Grant Stevenson, Minnesota State | Brandon Bochenski, North Dakota | Troy Riddle, Minnesota | |
| |
| |
2003-04 |
| First Team | Second Team | Third Team | |
| G | Bernd Bruckler, Wisconsin | Isaac Reichmuth, Minnesota-Duluth | Adam Berkhoel, Denver | |
| D | Keith Ballard, Minnesota | Ryan Caldwell, Denver | Mark Stuart, Colorado College | |
| D | Beau Geisler, Minnesota-Duluth | Matt Jones, North Dakota | Ryan Suter, Wisconsin | |
| F | Junior Lessard, Minnesota-Duluth | Chris Conner, Michigan Tech. | Shane Joseph, Minnesota State | |
| F | Brandon Bochenski, North Dakota | Thomas Vanek, Minnesota | Brady Murray, North Dakota | |
| F | Zach Parise, North Dakota | Evan Schwabe, Minnesota-Duluth | Gabe Gauthier, Denver | |
| |
| |
2004-05 |
| First Team | Second Team | Third Team | |
| G | Curtis McElhinney, Colorado College | Bernd Bruckler, Wisconsin | Cam Ellsworth, Michigan Tech. | |
| D | Matt Carle, Denver | Lars Helminen, Michigan Tech. | Tom Gilbert, Wisconsin | |
| D | Brett Skinner, Denver | Mark Stuart, Colorado College | Matt Jones, North Dakota | |
| F | Marty Sertich, Colorado College | Gabe Gauthier, Denver | David Backes, Minnesota State | |
| F | Brett Sterling, Colorado College | Evan Schwabe, Minnesota-Duluth | Ryan Potulny, Minnesota | |
| F | Colin Murphy, Michigan Tech. | Robbie Earl, Wisconsin | Danny Irmen, Minnesota | |
| |
| |
2005-06 |
| First Team | Second Team | Third Team | |
| G | Bobby Goepfert, St. Cloud State | Brian Elliott, Wisconsin | Jordan Parise, North Dakota | |
| D | Matt Carle, Denver | Alex Goligoski, Minnesota | Chris Harrington, Minnesota | |
| D | Tom Gilbert, Wisconsin | Brian Salcido, Colorado College | Matt Smaby, North Dakota | |
| F | Ryan Potulny, Minnesota | Joe Pavelski, Wisconsin | Drew Stafford, North Dakota | |
| F | Brett Sterling, Colorado College | Marty Sertich, Colorado College | Ryan Dingle, Denver | |
| F | Paul Stastny, Denver | David Backes, Minnesota State | Danny Irmen, Minnesota | |
| |
| |
2006-07 |
| First Team | Second Team | Third Team | |
| G | Bobby Goepfert, St. Cloud State | Brian Elliott, Wisconsin | Michael-Lee Teslak, Michigan Tech. | |
| D | Alex Goligoski, Minnesota | Mike Vannelli, Minnesota | Lee Sweatt, Colorado College | |
| D | Matt Niskanen, Minnesota-Duluth | Taylor Chorney, North Dakota | Steve Wagner, Minnesota State | |
| F | Ryan Duncan, North Dakota | Jonathan Toews, North Dakota | Andreas Nodl, St. Cloud State | |
| F | Mason Raymond, Minnesota-Duluth | Travis Morin, Minnesota State | T.J. Oshie, North Dakota | |
| F | Andrew Gordon, St. Cloud State | Kyle Okposo, Minnesota | Ryan Dingle, Denver | |
| |
| |
2007-08 |
| First Team | Second Team | Third Team | |
| G | Richard Bachman, Colorado College | Jean-Philippe Lamoureux, North Dakota | Peter Mannino, Denver | |
| D | Jack Hillen, Colorado College | Chris Butler, Denver | Robbie Bina, North Dakota | |
| D | Taylor Chorney, North Dakota | Chay Genoway, North Dakota | Jamie McBain, Wisconsin | |
| F | Chad Rau, Colorado College | Andreas Nodl, St. Cloud State | Tyler Bozak, Denver | |
| F | T.J. Oshie, North Dakota | Ryan Duncan, North Dakota | Blake Wheeler, Minnesota | |
| F | Ryan Lasch, St. Cloud State | Garrett Roe, St. Cloud State | Kyle Turris, Wisconsin | |
| |
| |
2008-09 |
| First Team | Second Team | Third Team | |
| G | Alex Stalock, Minnesota-Duluth | Marc Cheverie, Denver | Brad Eidsness, North Dakota | |
| D | Jamie McBain, Wisconsin | Patrick Wiercioch, Denver | Josh Meyers, Minnesota-Duluth | |
| D | Chay Genoway, North Dakota | Garrett Raboin, St. Cloud State | Kurt Davis, Minnesota State | |
| F | Ryan Stoa, Minnesota | Ryan Duncan, North Dakota | Garrett Roe, St. Cloud State | |
| F | Chad Rau, Colorado College | Jordan Schroeder, Minnesota | Anthony Maiani, Denver | |
| F | Ryan Lasch, St. Cloud State | Justin Fontaine, Minnesota-Duluth | Rhett Rakhshani, Denver | |
| |
| |
2009-10 |
| First Team | Second Team | Third Team | |
| G | Marc Cheverie, Denver | Brad Eidsness, North Dakota | Dan Dunn, St. Cloud State | |
| D | Brendan Smith, Wisconsin | Ryan McDonagh, Wisconsin | Garrett Raboin, St. Cloud State | |
| D | Patrick Wiercioch, Denver | Nate Prosser, Colorado College | Chay Genoway, North Dakota | |
| F | Rhett Rakhshani, Denver | Justin Fontaine, Minnesota-Duluth | Michael Davies, Wisconsin | |
| F | Blake Geoffrion, Wisconsin | Ryan Lasch, St. Cloud State | Joe Colborne, Denver | |
| F | Jack Connolly, Minnesota-Duluth | Tyler Ruegsegger, Denver | Garrett Roe, St. Cloud State | |
| |
| |