| NCAA Division 3 Tournament | |
| | | | | | | | |
 |
| Stagg Bowl Champions | |
| 1973 | Wittenberg | |
| 1974 | Central | |
| 1975 | Wittenberg | |
| 1976 | St. John's | |
| 1977 | Widener | |
| 1978 | Baldwin-Wallace | |
| 1979 | Ithaca | |
| 1980 | Dayton | |
| 1981 | Widener | |
| 1982 | West Georgia | |
| 1983 | Augustana | |
| 1984 | Augustana | |
| 1985 | Augustana | |
| 1986 | Augustana | |
| 1987 | Wagner | |
| 1988 | Ithaca | |
| 1989 | Dayton | |
| 1990 | Allegheny | |
| 1991 | Ithaca | |
| 1992 | Wisconsin-La Crosse | |
| 1993 | Mount Union | |
| 1994 | Albion | |
| 1995 | Wisconsin-La Crosse | |
| 1996 | Mount Union | |
| 1997 | Mount Union | |
| 1998 | Mount Union | |
| 1999 | Pacific Lutheran | |
| 2000 | Mount Union | |
| 2001 | Mount Union | |
| 2002 | Mount Union | |
| 2003 | St. John's | |
| 2004 | Linfield | |
| 2005 | Mount Union | |
| 2006 | Mount Union | |
| 2007 | Wisconsin-Whitewater | |
| 2008 | Mount Union | |
| 2009 | Wisconsin-Whitewater | |
| |
 |
| ResultsHome team listed in all capitals. | |
| |
 |
| 1973 | |
| |
| Semifinals | |
| December 1 | |
| | Juniata 35, BRIDGEPORT 14 | |
| | WITTENBERG 21, San Diego 14 | |
| |
| Stagg Bowl | |
| December 8 | |
| | Wittenberg 41, Juniata 0 (in Phenix City, Alabama) | |
| |
 |
| 1974 | |
| |
| Semifinals | |
| November 30 | |
| | Central 17, EVANSVILLE 16 | |
| | ITHACA 27, Slippery Rock 14 | |
| |
| Stagg Bowl | |
| December 7 | |
| | Central 10, Ithaca 8 (in Phenix City, Alabama) | |
| |
 |
| 1975 | |
| |
| First Round | |
| November 22 | |
| | ITHACA 41, Fort Valley State 12 | |
| | Millsaps 28, COLORADO COLLEGE 21 | |
| | WIDENER 14, Albright 6 | |
| | WITTENBERG 17, Indiana Central 13 | |
| |
| Semifinals | |
| November 29 | |
| | ITHACA 23, Widener 14 | |
| | WITTENBERG 55, Millsaps 22 | |
| |
| Stagg Bowl | |
| December 6 | |
| | Wittenberg 28, Ithaca 0 (in Phenix City, Alabama) | |
| |
 |
| 1976 | |
| |
| First Round | |
| November 20 | |
| | Buena Vista 20, CARROLL 14 (ot) | |
| | St. John's 46, AUGUSTANA 7 | |
| | ST. LAWRENCE 26, Albright 7 | |
| | Towson State 14, C.W. POST 10 | |
| |
| Semifinals | |
| November 27 | |
| | ST. JOHN'S 61, Buena Vista 0 | |
| | TOWSON STATE 38, St. Lawrence 36 | |
| |
| Stagg Bowl | |
| December 4 | |
| | St. John's 31, Towson State 28 (in Phenix City, Alabama) | |
| |
 |
| 1977 | |
| |
| First Round | |
| November 19 | |
| | Albany 51, HAMPDEN-SYDNEY 45 | |
| | MINNESOTA-MORRIS 13, Albion 10 | |
| | Wabash 20, ST. JOHN'S 9 | |
| | Widener 19, CENTRAL 0 | |
| |
| Semifinals | |
| November 26 | |
| | WABASH 37, Minnesota-Morris 21 | |
| | WIDENER 33, Albany 15 | |
| |
| Stagg Bowl | |
| December 3 | |
| | Widener 39, Wabash 36 (in Phenix City, Alabama) | |
| |
 |
| 1978 | |
| |
| First Round | |
| November 18 | |
| | BALDWIN-WALLACE 71, St. Lawrence 7 | |
| | CARNEGIE MELLON 24, Dayton 21 | |
| | MINNESOTA-MORRIS 23, St. Olaf 10 | |
| | Wittenberg 6, ITHACA 3 | |
| |
| Semifinals | |
| November 25 | |
| | BALDWIN-WALLACE 31, Carnegie Mellon 6 | |
| | WITTENBERG 35, Minnesota-Morris 14 | |
| |
| Stagg Bowl | |
| December 2 | |
| | Baldwin-Wallace 24, Wittenberg 10 (in Phenix City, Alabama) | |
| |
 |
| 1979 | |
| |
| First Round | |
| November 17 | |
| | CARNEGIE MELLON 31, Minnesota-Morris 25 (ot) | |
| | Ithaca 27, DUBUQUE 7 | |
| | WIDENER 29, Baldwin-Wallace 8 | |
| | Wittenberg 21, MILLERSVILLE 14 | |
| |
| Semifinals | |
| November 24 | |
| | ITHACA 15, Carnegie Mellon 6 | |
| | WITTENBERG 17, Widener 14 | |
| |
| Stagg Bowl | |
| December 1 | |
| | Ithaca 14, Wittenberg 10 (in Phenix City, Alabama) | |
| |
 |
| 1980 | |
| |
| First Round | |
| November 22 | |
| | DAYTON 34, Baldwin-Wallace 0 | |
| | ITHACA 41, Wagner 13 | |
| | MINNESOTA-MORRIS 41, Dubuque 35 | |
| | Widener 43, BETHANY 12 | |
| |
| Semifinals | |
| November 29 | |
| | Dayton 28, WIDENER 24 | |
| | ITHACA 36, Minnesota-Morris 0 | |
| |
| Stagg Bowl | |
| December 6 | |
| | Dayton 63, Ithaca 0 (in Phenix City, Alabama) | |
| |
 |
| 1981 | |
| |
| First Round | |
| November 21 | |
| | DAYTON 19, Augustana 7 | |
| | LAWRENCE 21, Minnesota-Morris 14 (ot) | |
| | Montclair State 13, ALFRED 12 | |
| | Widener 10, WEST GEORGIA 3 | |
| |
| Semifinals | |
| November 28 | |
| | DAYTON 38, Lawrence 0 | |
| | WIDENER 23, Montclair State 12 | |
| |
| Stagg Bowl | |
| December 5 | |
| | Widener 17, Dayton 10 (in Phenix City, Alabama) | |
| |
 |
| 1982 | |
| |
| First Round | |
| November 20 | |
| | Augustana 28, BALDWIN-WALLACE 22 | |
| | Bishop 32, WARTBURG 7 | |
| | St. Lawrence 43, WAGNER 34 | |
| | WEST GEORGIA 31, Widener 24 (ot) | |
| |
| Semifinals | |
| November 27 | |
| | AUGUSTANA 14, St. Lawrence 0 | |
| | WEST GEORGIA 27, Bishop 6 | |
| |
| Stagg Bowl | |
| December 4 | |
| | West Georgia 14, Augustana 0 (in Phenix City, Alabama) | |
| |
 |
| 1983 | |
| |
| First Round | |
| November 19 | |
| | AUGUSTANA 22, Adrian 21 | |
| | Salisbury 16, CARNEGIE MELLON 14 | |
| | Union 51, HOFSTRA 19 | |
| | Wisconsin-La Crosse 43, OCCIDENTAL 42 | |
| |
| Semifinals | |
| November 26 | |
| | AUGUSTANA 21, Wisconsin-La Crosse 15 | |
| | Union 23, SALISBURY 21 | |
| |
| Stagg Bowl | |
| December 3 | |
| | Augustana 21, Union 17 (in Kings Mills, Ohio) | |
| |
 |
| 1984 | |
| |
| First Round | |
| November 17 | |
| | Augustana 14, DAYTON 13 | |
| | CENTRAL 23, Occidental 22 | |
| | UNION 26, Plymouth State 14 | |
| | Washington and Jefferson 22, RANDOLPH-MACON 21 | |
| |
| Semifinals | |
| November 24 | |
| | AUGUSTANA 23, Union 6 | |
| | CENTRAL 20, Washington and Jefferson 0 | |
| |
| Stagg Bowl | |
| December 8 | |
| | Augustana 21, Central 12 (in Kings Mills, Ohio) | |
| |
 |
| 1985 | |
| |
| First Round | |
| November 23 | |
| | AUGUSTANA 26, Albion 10 | |
| | CENTRAL 27, Coe 7 | |
| | GETTYSBURG 14, Lycoming 10 | |
| | Ithaca 13, UNION 12 | |
| | MONTCLAIR STATE 28, Western Connecticut 0 | |
| | MOUNT UNION 35, Denison 3 | |
| | OCCIDENTAL 28, St. John's 10 | |
| | SALISBURY 35, Carnegie Mellon 22 | |
| |
| Quarterfinals | |
| November 30 | |
| | AUGUSTANA 21, Mount Union 14 | |
| | CENTRAL 71, Occidental 0 | |
| | GETTYSBURG 22, Salisbury 6 | |
| | ITHACA 50, Montclair State 28 | |
| |
| Semifinals | |
| December 7 | |
| | AUGUSTANA 14, Central 7 | |
| | ITHACA 34, Gettysburg 0 | |
| |
| Stagg Bowl | |
| December 14 | |
| | Augustana 20, Ithaca 7 (in Phenix City, Alabama) | |
| |
 |
| 1986 | |
| |
| First Round | |
| November 22 | |
| | Augustana 34, HOPE 10 | |
| | Central 37, BUENA VISTA 0 | |
| | CONCORDIA-MOORHEAD 24, Wisconsin-Stevens Point 15 | |
| | Ithaca 24, UNION 17 (ot) | |
| | Montclair State 24, HOFSTRA 21 | |
| | Mount Union 42, DAYTON 36 | |
| | Salisbury 34, Emory and Henry 20 (in Bristol, Tennessee) | |
| | Susquehanna 28, WASHINGTON AND JEFFERSON 20 | |
| |
| Quarterfinals | |
| November 29 | |
| | Augustana 16, MOUNT UNION 7 | |
| | Concordia-Moorhead 17, CENTRAL 14 | |
| | ITHACA 29, Montclair State 15 | |
| | Salisbury 31, SUSQUEHANNA 17 | |
| |
| Semifinals | |
| December 6 | |
| | AUGUSTANA 41, Concordia-Moorhead 7 | |
| | Salisbury 44, ITHACA 40 | |
| |
| Stagg Bowl | |
| December 13 | |
| | Augustana 31, Salisbury 3 (in Phenix City, Alabama) | |
| |
 |
| 1987 | |
| |
| First Round | |
| November 21 | |
| | AUGUSTANA 53, Hiram 0 | |
| | CENTRAL 17, Menlo 0 | |
| | DAYTON 52, Capital 28 | |
| | Emory and Henry 49, Ferrum 7 (in Roanoke, Virginia) | |
| | Fordham 41, HOFSTRA 6 | |
| | St. John's 7, GUSTAVUS ADOLPHUS 3 | |
| | WAGNER 38, Rochester 14 | |
| | Washington and Jefferson 23, ALLEGHENY 17 (ot) | |
| |
| Quarterfinals | |
| November 28 | |
| | CENTRAL 13, St. John's 3 | |
| | DAYTON 38, Augustana 36 | |
| | Emory and Henry 23, WASHINGTON AND JEFFERSON 16 | |
| | Wagner 21, FORDHAM 0 | |
| |
| Semifinals | |
| December 5 | |
| | DAYTON 34, Central 0 | |
| | Wagner 20, EMORY AND HENRY 15 | |
| |
| Stagg Bowl | |
| December 12 | |
| | Wagner 19, Dayton 3 (in Phenix City, Alabama) | |
| |
 |
| 1988 | |
| |
| Regionals | |
| November 19 | |
| | AUGUSTANA 25, Adrian 7 | |
| | Central 7, CONCORDIA-MOORHEAD 0 | |
| | CORTLAND 32, Hofstra 27 | |
| | Ferrum 34, Rhodes 10 (in Rocky Mount, Virginia) | |
| | Ithaca 34, WAGNER 31 (ot) | |
| | MORAVIAN 17, Widener 7 | |
| | Wisconsin-Whitewater 29, SIMPSON 27 | |
| | Wittenberg 35, DAYTON 28 (ot) | |
| |
| Quarterfinals | |
| November 26 | |
| | Augustana 28, WITTENBERG 14 | |
| | Central 16, WISCONSIN-WHITEWATER 13 | |
| | Ferrum 49, Moravian 28 (in Rocky Mount, Virginia) | |
| | ITHACA 24, Cortland 17 | |
| |
| Semifinals | |
| December 3 | |
| | CENTRAL 23, Augustana 17 (ot) | |
| | ITHACA 62, Ferrum 28 | |
| |
| Stagg Bowl | |
| December 10 | |
| | Ithaca 39, Central 24 (in Phenix City, Alabama) | |
| |
 |
| 1989 | |
| |
| Regionals | |
| November 18 | |
| | CENTRAL 55, St. Norbert 7 | |
| | DAYTON 35, John Carroll 10 | |
| | Ferrum 41, Washington and Jefferson 7 (in Rocky Mount, Virginia) | |
| | Lycoming 21, DICKINSON 0 | |
| | MILLIKIN 21, Augustana 12 | |
| | MONTCLAIR STATE 23, Hofstra 6 | |
| | ST. JOHN'S 42, Simpson 35 | |
| | UNION 42, Cortland 14 | |
| |
| Quarterfinals | |
| November 25 | |
| | DAYTON 28, Millikin 16 | |
| | Ferrum 49, LYCOMING 24 | |
| | St. John's 27, CENTRAL 24 | |
| | UNION 45, Montclair State 6 | |
| |
| Semifinals | |
| December 2 | |
| | DAYTON 28, St. John's 0 | |
| | Union 37, Ferrum 21 (in Rocky Mount, Virginia) | |
| |
| Stagg Bowl | |
| December 9 | |
| | Dayton 17, Union 7 (in Phenix City, Alabama) | |
| |
 |
| 1990 | |
| |
| Regionals | |
| November 17 | |
| | Allegheny 26, MOUNT UNION 15 | |
| | CENTRAL 24, Redlands 14 | |
| | DAYTON 24, Augustana 14 | |
| | HOFSTRA 35, Cortland 9 | |
| | LYCOMING 17, Carnegie Mellon 7 | |
| | St. Thomas 24, WISCONSIN-WHITEWATER 23 | |
| | Trenton State 24, ITHACA 14 | |
| | WASHINGTON AND JEFFERSON 10, Ferrum 7 | |
| |
| Quarterfinals | |
| November 24 | |
| | ALLEGHENY 31, Dayton 23 | |
| | Central 33, ST. THOMAS 32 | |
| | Hofstra 38, TRENTON STATE 3 | |
| | Lycoming 24, WASHINGTON AND JEFFERSON 0 | |
| |
| Semifinals | |
| December 1 | |
| | Allegheny 24, CENTRAL 7 | |
| | Lycoming 20, HOFSTRA 10 | |
| |
| Stagg Bowl | |
| December 8 | |
| | Allegheny 21, Lycoming 14 (ot) (in Bradenton, Florida) | |
| |
 |
| 1991 | |
| |
| Regionals | |
| November 23 | |
| | ALLEGHENY 24, Albion 21 (ot) | |
| | DAYTON 27, Baldwin-Wallace 10 | |
| | ITHACA 31, Glassboro State 10 | |
| | LYCOMING 18, Washington and Jefferson 16 | |
| | ST. JOHN'S 75, Coe 2 | |
| | Susquehanna 21, DICKINSON 20 | |
| | UNION 55, Massachusetts-Lowell 16 | |
| November 24 | |
| | Wisconsin-La Crosse 28, Simpson 13 (in Cedar Falls, Iowa) | |
| |
| Quarterfinals | |
| November 30 | |
| | Dayton 28, ALLEGHENY 25 (ot) | |
| | ITHACA 35, Union 23 | |
| | St. John's 29, Wisconsin-La Crosse 10 (in Minneapolis, Minnesota) | |
| | SUSQUEHANNA 31, Lycoming 24 | |
| |
| Semifinals | |
| December 7 | |
| | DAYTON 19, St. John's 7 | |
| | Ithaca 49, SUSQUEHANNA 13 | |
| |
| Stagg Bowl | |
| December 14 | |
| | Ithaca 34, Dayton 20 (in Bradenton, Florida) | |
| |
 |
| 1992 | |
| |
| Regionals | |
| November 21 | |
| | Buffalo State 28, ITHACA 26 | |
| | CENTRAL 20, Carleton 8 | |
| | EMORY AND HENRY 17, Thomas More 0 | |
| | ILLINOIS WESLEYAN 21, Aurora 12 | |
| | Mount Union 27, DAYTON 10 | |
| | ROWAN 41, WPI 14 | |
| | Washington and Jefferson 33, LYCOMING 0 | |
| | WISCONSIN-LA CROSSE 47, Redlands 26 | |
| |
| Quarterfinals | |
| November 28 | |
| | MOUNT UNION 49, Illinois Wesleyan 27 | |
| | Rowan 28, BUFFALO STATE 19 | |
| | WASHINGTON AND JEFFERSON 51, Emory and Henry 15 | |
| | Wisconsin-La Crosse 34, Central 9 (in Ames, Iowa) | |
| |
| Semifinals | |
| December 5 | |
| | Washington and Jefferson 18, ROWAN 13 | |
| | WISCONSIN-LA CROSSE 29, Mount Union 24 | |
| |
| Stagg Bowl | |
| December 12 | |
| | Wisconsin-La Crosse 16, Washington and Jefferson 12 (in Bradenton, | |
| |
 |
| 1993 | |
| |
| Regionals | |
| November 20 | |
| | ALBION 41, Anderson 21 | |
| | Frostburg State 26, WILKES 25 | |
| | MOUNT UNION 40, Allegheny 7 | |
| | ROWAN 29, Buffalo State 6 | |
| | ST. JOHN'S 32, Coe 14 | |
| | WASHINGTON AND JEFFERSON 27, Moravian 7 | |
| | William Paterson 17, UNION 7 | |
| | WISCONSIN-LA CROSSE 55, Wartburg 26 | |
| |
| Quarterfinals | |
| November 27 | |
| | MOUNT UNION 30, Albion 16 | |
| | Rowan 37, WILLIAM PATERSON 0 | |
| | St. John's 47, WISCONSIN-LA CROSSE 25 | |
| | Washington and Jefferson 28, FROSTBURG STATE 7 | |
| |
| Semifinals | |
| December 4 | |
| | MOUNT UNION 56, St. John's 8 | |
| | Rowan 23, WASHINGTON AND JEFFERSON 16 | |
| |
| Stagg Bowl | |
| December 11 | |
| | Mount Union 34, Rowan 24 (in Salem, Virginia) | |
| |
 |
| 1994 | |
| |
| Regionals | |
| November 19 | |
| | ALBION 28, Augustana 21 | |
| | ITHACA 10, Buffalo State 7 (ot) | |
| | Mount Union 28, ALLEGHENY 19 | |
| | PLYMOUTH STATE 19, Merchant Marine 18 | |
| | ST. JOHN'S 51, La Verne 12 | |
| | Wartburg 22, CENTRAL 21 | |
| | Washington and Jefferson 28, TRINITY (TX) 0 | |
| | Widener 14, DICKINSON 0 | |
| |
| Quarterfinals | |
| November 26 | |
| | ALBION 34, Mount Union 33 | |
| | Ithaca 22, PLYMOUTH STATE 7 | |
| | ST. JOHN'S 42, Wartburg 14 | |
| | WASHINGTON AND JEFFERSON 37, Widener 21 | |
| |
| Semifinals | |
| December 3 | |
| | Albion 19, ST. JOHN'S 16 | |
| | Washington and Jefferson 23, ITHACA 19 | |
| |
| Stagg Bowl | |
| December 10 | |
| | Albion 38, Washington and Jefferson 15 (in Salem, Virginia) | |
| |
 |
| 1995 | |
| |
| Regionals | |
| November 18 | |
| | LYCOMING 31, Widener 27 | |
| | MOUNT UNION 52, Hanover 18 | |
| | Rowan 46, BUFFALO STATE 7 | |
| | Union 24, PLYMOUTH STATE 7 | |
| | WASHINGTON AND JEFFERSON 35, Emory and Henry 16 | |
| | WHEATON 63, Wittenberg 41 | |
| | Wisconsin-La Crosse 45, Concordia-Moorhead 7 (in Fargo, North Dakota) | |
| | Wisconsin-River Falls 10, CENTRAL 7 | |
| |
| Quarterfinals | |
| November 25 | |
| | MOUNT UNION 40, Wheaton 14 | |
| | ROWAN 38, Union 7 | |
| | WASHINGTON AND JEFFERSON 48, Lycoming 0 | |
| | WISCONSIN-LA CROSSE 28, Wisconsin-River Falls 14 | |
| |
| Semifinals | |
| December 2 | |
| | Rowan 28, WASHINGTON AND JEFFERSON 15 | |
| | Wisconsin-La Crosse 20, MOUNT UNION 17 | |
| |
| Stagg Bowl | |
| December 9 | |
| | Wisconsin-La Crosse 36, Rowan 7 (in Salem, Virginia) | |
| |
 |
| 1996 | |
| |
| Regionals | |
| November 23 | |
| | Albright 31, WASHINGTON AND JEFFERSON 17 | |
| | COLLEGE OF NEW JERSEY 17, Coast Guard 16 | |
| | Illinois Wesleyan 23, ALBION 20 | |
| | LYCOMING 31, Ursinus 24 | |
| | MOUNT UNION 31, Allegheny 26 | |
| | Rowan 21, BUFFALO STATE 20 | |
| | St. John's 21, Simpson 18 (in Minneapolis, Minnesota) | |
| | WISCONSIN-LA CROSSE 44, Wisconsin-River Falls 0 | |
| |
| Quarterfinals | |
| November 30 | |
| | LYCOMING 31, Albright 13 | |
| | MOUNT UNION 49, Illinois Wesleyan 14 | |
| | Rowan 7, COLLEGE OF NEW JERSEY 3 | |
| | WISCONSIN-LA CROSSE 37, St. John's 30 | |
| |
| Semifinals | |
| December 7 | |
| | Mount Union 39, Wisconsin-La Crosse 21 (in Madison, Wisconsin) | |
| | ROWAN 33, Lycoming 14 | |
| |
| Stagg Bowl | |
| December 14 | |
| | Mount Union 56, Rowan 24 (in Salem, Virginia) | |
| |
 |
| 1997 | |
| |
| First Round | |
| November 22 | |
| | Augsburg 34, Concordia-Moorhead 22 (in Fargo, North Dakota) | |
| | College of New Jersey 34, CORTLAND 30 | |
| | John Carroll 30, HANOVER 20 | |
| | LYCOMING 27, Western Maryland 13 | |
| | MOUNT UNION 34, Allegheny 30 | |
| | ROWAN 43, Coast Guard 0 | |
| | Simpson 34, WISCONSIN-WHITEWATER 31 | |
| | TRINITY (TX) 44, Catholic 33 | |
| |
| Quarterfinals | |
| November 29 | |
| | LYCOMING 46, Trinity (TX) 26 | |
| | MOUNT UNION 59, John Carroll 7 | |
| | ROWAN 13, College of New Jersey 7 | |
| | SIMPSON 61, Augsburg 21 | |
| |
| Semifinals | |
| December 6 | |
| | LYCOMING 28, Rowan 20 | |
| | MOUNT UNION 54, Simpson 7 | |
| |
| Stagg Bowl | |
| December 13 | |
| | Mount Union 61, Lycoming 12 (in Salem, Virginia) | |
| |
 |
| 1998 | |
| |
| First Round | |
| November 21 | |
| | Buffalo State 38, SPRINGFIELD 35 | |
| | LYCOMING 49, Catholic 14 | |
| | MOUNT UNION 21, Albion 19 | |
| | Rowan 26, COLLEGE OF NEW JERSEY 2 | |
| | ST. JOHN'S 33, Pacific Lutheran 20 | |
| | TRINITY (TX) 30, Western Maryland 20 | |
| | Wisconsin-Eau Claire 28, CENTRAL 21 | |
| | WITTENBERG 13, Millikin 10 | |
| |
| Quarterfinals | |
| November 28 | |
| | MOUNT UNION 21, Wittenberg 19 | |
| | ROWAN 19, Buffalo State 17 | |
| | Trinity (TX) 37, LYCOMING 21 | |
| | Wisconsin-Eau Claire 10, ST. JOHN'S 7 | |
| |
| Semifinals | |
| December 5 | |
| | MOUNT UNION 34, Trinity (TX) 29 | |
| | ROWAN 22, Wisconsin-Eau Claire 19 | |
| |
| Stagg Bowl | |
| December 12 | |
| | Mount Union 44, Rowan 24 (in Salem, Virginia) | |
| |
 |
| 1999 | |
| |
| First Round | |
| November 20 | |
| | AUGUSTANA 39, St. Norbert 32 | |
| | Central 38, WISCONSIN-LA CROSSE 17 | |
| | HARDIN-SIMMONS 28, Washington 21 | |
| | MONTCLAIR STATE 37, Buffalo State 34 | |
| | Ohio Northern 56, HANOVER 14 | |
| | Pacific Lutheran 28, WILLAMETTE 24 | |
| | Rowan 29, RENSSELAER 10 | |
| | ST. JOHN'S 23, Wisconsin-Stevens Point 10 | |
| | Ursinus 43, BRIDGEWATER STATE 38 | |
| | Washington and Jefferson 14, LYCOMING 7 | |
| | WESTERN MARYLAND 20, Catholic 16 | |
| | WITTENBERG 42, Alma 19 | |
| |
| Second Round | |
| November 27 | |
| | HARDIN-SIMMONS 51, Washington and Jefferson 3 | |
| | Montclair State 32, WESTERN CONNECTICUT 24 | |
| | MOUNT UNION 42, Augustana 33 | |
| | Ohio Northern 58, WITTENBERG 24 | |
| | Pacific Lutheran 49, WARTBURG 14 | |
| | ROWAN 55, Ursinus 0 | |
| | ST. JOHN'S 10, Central 9 | |
| | TRINITY (TX) 20, Western Maryland 16 | |
| |
| Quarterfinals | |
| December 4 | |
| | MOUNT UNION 56, Ohio Northern 31 | |
| | Pacific Lutheran 19, ST. JOHN'S 9 | |
| | Rowan 42, MONTCLAIR STATE 13 | |
| | TRINITY (TX) 40, Hardin-Simmons 33 | |
| |
| Semifinals | |
| December 11 | |
| | Pacific Lutheran 49, TRINITY (TX) 28 | |
| | Rowan 24, MOUNT UNION 17 (ot) | |
| |
| Stagg Bowl | |
| December 18 | |
| | Pacific Lutheran 42, Rowan 13 (in Salem, Virginia) | |
| |
 |
| 2000 | |
| |
| First Round | |
| November 18 | |
| | Bridgewater 59, WASHINGTON AND JEFFERSON 42 | |
| | CENTRAL 29, St. Norbert 14 | |
| | Hanover 20, HOPE 3 | |
| | HOBART 25, Bridgewater State 0 | |
| | OHIO NORTHERN 47, Millikin 21 | |
| | Pacific Lutheran 41, BETHEL 13 | |
| | SPRINGFIELD 31, Montclair State 29 | |
| | St. John's 26, WISCONSIN-STOUT 19 | |
| | TRINITY (TX) 21, Wesley 3 | |
| | Western Maryland 38, EMORY AND HENRY 14 | |
| | Widener 33, UNION 26 | |
| | WITTENBERG 31, Aurora 20 | |
| |
| Second Round | |
| November 25 | |
| | Central 20, LINFIELD 17 (ot) | |
| | HARDIN-SIMMONS 32, Western Maryland 10 | |
| | MOUNT UNION 59, Ohio Northern 28 | |
| | Springfield 13, BROCKPORT 6 | |
| | St. John's 28, PACIFIC LUTHERAN 21 (ot) | |
| | TRINITY (TX) 47, Bridgewater 41 (ot) | |
| | WIDENER 40, Hobart 14 | |
| | WITTENBERG 32, Hanover 21 | |
| |
| Quarterfinals | |
| December 2 | |
| | HARDIN-SIMMONS 33, Trinity (TX) 30 | |
| | MOUNT UNION 32, Wittenberg 15 | |
| | St. John's 21, CENTRAL 18 | |
| | Widener 61, SPRINGFIELD 27 | |
| |
| Semifinals | |
| December 9 | |
| | MOUNT UNION 70, Widener 30 | |
| | St. John's 38, HARDIN-SIMMONS 14 | |
| |
| Stagg Bowl | |
| December 16 | |
| | Mount Union 10, St. John's 7 (in Salem, Virginia) | |
| |
 |
| 2001 | |
| |
| First Round | |
| November 17 | |
| | AUGUSTANA 54, Defiance 14 | |
| | Ithaca 35, MONTCLAIR STATE 23 | |
| | Pacific Lutheran 27, WHITWORTH 26 (ot) | |
| | ROWAN 40, Brockport 17 | |
| | ST. JOHN'S 27, St. Norbert 20 | |
| | THOMAS MORE 34, MacMurray 30 | |
| | TRINITY (TX) 30, Mary Hardin-Baylor 6 | |
| | WASHINGTON AND JEFFERSON 24, Western Maryland 21 | |
| | Western Connecticut 8, WESTFIELD STATE 7 | |
| | WIDENER 56, Christopher Newport 7 | |
| | WISCONSIN-STEVENS POINT 37, Bethel 27 | |
| | Wittenberg 38, HARDIN-SIMMONS 35 (ot) | |
| |
| Second Round | |
| November 24 | |
| | BRIDGEWATER 41, Trinity (TX) 37 | |
| | Ithaca 27, RENSSELAER 10 | |
| | MOUNT UNION 32, Augustana 7 | |
| | Pacific Lutheran 27, CENTRAL 21 (ot) | |
| | ROWAN 43, Western Connecticut 14 | |
| | ST. JOHN'S 9, Wisconsin-Stevens Point 7 | |
| | WIDENER 46, Washington and Jefferson 30 | |
| | Wittenberg 41, THOMAS MORE 0 | |
| |
| Quarterfinals | |
| December 1 | |
| | BRIDGEWATER 57, Widener 32 | |
| | MOUNT UNION 49, Wittenberg 21 | |
| | ROWAN 48, Ithaca 0 | |
| | St. John's 31, Pacific Lutheran 6 (in Fargo, North Dakota) | |
| |
| Semifinals | |
| December 8 | |
| | BRIDGEWATER 29, Rowan 24 | |
| | MOUNT UNION 35, St. John's 14 | |
| |
| Stagg Bowl | |
| December 15 | |
| | Mount Union 30, Bridgewater 27 (in Salem, Virginia) | |
| |
 |
| 2002 | |
| |
| First Round | |
| November 23 | |
| | BROCKPORT 16, Springfield 0 | |
| | COE 21, Wisconsin-La Crosse 18 | |
| | John Carroll 27, HOBART 7 | |
| | KING'S 28, Salisbury 0 | |
| | MUHLENBERG 56, Massachusetts-Dartmouth 6 | |
| | ST. JOHN'S 31, Redlands 24 | |
| | TRINITY (TX) 48, Mary Hardin-Baylor 38 | |
| | WABASH 42, MacMurray 7 | |
| | WARTBURG 45, Lake Forest 0 | |
| | WASHINGTON AND JEFFERSON 24, Christopher Newport 10 | |
| | Wheaton 42, ALMA 14 | |
| | Wittenberg 34, HANOVER 33 | |
| |
| Second Round | |
| November 30 | |
| | BRIDGEWATER 19, King's 17 | |
| | Brockport 15, ROWAN 12 | |
| | John Carroll 21, MUHLENBERG 10 | |
| | LINFIELD 52, Wartburg 15 | |
| | MOUNT UNION 42, Wheaton 21 | |
| | ST. JOHN'S 45, Coe 14 | |
| | TRINITY (TX) 45, Washington and Jefferson 10 | |
| | WABASH 25, Wittenberg 14 | |
| |
| Quarterfinals | |
| December 7 | |
| | John Carroll 16, Brockport 10 (ot) (in Rochester, New York) | |
| | MOUNT UNION 45, Wabash 16 | |
| | St. John's 21, LINFIELD 14 | |
| | Trinity (TX) 38, BRIDGEWATER 32 | |
| |
| Semifinals | |
| December 14 | |
| | MOUNT UNION 57, John Carroll 19 | |
| | TRINITY (TX) 41, St. John's 34 | |
| |
| Stagg Bowl | |
| December 21 | |
| | Mount Union 48, Trinity (TX) 7 (in Salem, Virginia) | |
| |
 |
| 2003 | |
| |
| First Round | |
| November 22 | |
| | BALDWIN-WALLACE 54, Hanover 32 | |
| | BRIDGEWATER 28, Waynesburg 24 | |
| | CHRISTOPHER NEWPORT 24, Muhlenberg 20 | |
| | EAST TEXAS BAPTIST 42, Trinity (TX) 41 (ot) | |
| | Ithaca 14, BROCKPORT 9 | |
| | LINFIELD 31, Redlands 23 | |
| | MONTCLAIR STATE 20, Allegheny 19 | |
| | RENSSELAER 34, Curry 20 | |
| | ST. NORBERT 26, Simpson 20 (ot) | |
| | WARTBURG 21, Bethel 7 | |
| | WHEATON 55, Hope 45 | |
| | WISCONSIN-LA CROSSE 52, Concordia (WI) 13 | |
| |
| Second Round | |
| November 29 | |
| | Bridgewater 26, CHRISTOPHER NEWPORT 3 | |
| | Ithaca 33, MONTCLAIR STATE 13 | |
| | Linfield 23, Wartburg 20 (in Salem, Oregon) | |
| | LYCOMING 13, East Texas Baptist 7 (ot) | |
| | MOUNT UNION 39, Wisconsin-La Crosse 14 | |
| | Rensselaer 40, SPRINGFIELD 34 | |
| | ST. JOHN'S 38, St. Norbert 13 | |
| | WHEATON 16, Baldwin-Wallace 12 | |
| |
| Quarterfinals | |
| December 6 | |
| | MOUNT UNION 56, Wheaton 10 | |
| | RENSSELAER 21, Ithaca 16 | |
| | ST. JOHN'S 31, Linfield 25 | |
| December 7 | |
| | Bridgewater 13, LYCOMING 9 | |
| |
| Semifinals | |
| December 13 | |
| | MOUNT UNION 66, Bridgewater 0 | |
| | ST. JOHN'S 38, Rensselaer 10 | |
| |
| Stagg Bowl | |
| December 20 | |
| | St. John's 24, Mount Union 6 (in Salem, Virginia) | |
| |
 |
| 2004 | |
| |
| First Round | |
| November 20 | |
| | Carthage 31, ALMA 28 | |
| | Christopher Newport 35, SALISBURY 24 | |
| | CONCORDIA-MOORHEAD 28, Wartburg 14 | |
| | DELAWARE VALLEY 21, Shenandoah 17 | |
| | HOBART 35, Curry 16 | |
| | Mary Hardin-Baylor 32, TRINITY (TX) 13 | |
| | OCCIDENTAL 28, Willamette 14 | |
| | ST. JOHN FISHER 31, Muhlenberg 3 | |
| | WASHINGTON AND JEFFERSON 55, Bridgewater 48 (ot) | |
| | WHEATON 31, Mount St. Joseph 7 | |
| | WISCONSIN-LA CROSSE 37, St. Norbert 23 | |
| | WOOSTER 41, Aurora 34 | |
| |
| Second Round | |
| November 27 | |
| | Carthage 14, WOOSTER 7 | |
| | DELAWARE VALLEY 26, St. John Fisher 20 | |
| | LINFIELD 52, Wisconsin-La Crosse 14 | |
| | Mary Hardin-Baylor 42, HARDIN-SIMMONS 28 | |
| | MOUNT UNION 27, Wheaton 6 | |
| | Occidental 42, Concordia-Moorhead 40 (in Fargo, North Dakota) | |
| | ROWAN 45, Hobart 14 | |
| | WASHINGTON AND JEFFERSON 24, Christopher Newport 14 | |
| |
| Quarterfinals | |
| December 4 | |
| | LINFIELD 56, Occidental 27 | |
| | Mary Hardin-Baylor 52, WASHINGTON AND JEFFERSON 16 | |
| | MOUNT UNION 38, Carthage 20 | |
| | ROWAN 56, Delaware Valley 7 | |
| |
| Semifinals | |
| December 11 | |
| | LINFIELD 52, Rowan 0 | |
| | Mary Hardin-Baylor 38, MOUNT UNION 35 | |
| |
| Stagg Bowl | |
| December 18 | |
| | Linfield 28, Mary Hardin-Baylor 21 (in Salem, Virginia) | |
| |
 |
| 2005 | |
| |
| First Round | |
| November 19 | |
| | AUGUSTANA 49, Lakeland 22 | |
| | BRIDGEWATER 30, Washington and Jefferson 21 | |
| | Capital 21, NORTH CENTRAL 19 | |
| | CONCORDIA-MOORHEAD 27, Coe 14 | |
| | DELAWARE VALLEY 37, Curry 22 | |
| | HOBART 23, Cortland 22 | |
| | LINFIELD 63, Occidental 21 | |
| | Mary Hardin-Baylor 35, TRINITY (TX) 6 | |
| | MOUNT UNION 49, Mount St. Joseph 6 | |
| | ROWAN 42, Wilkes 3 | |
| | ST. JOHN'S 62, Monmouth 3 | |
| | THIEL 28, Johns Hopkins 3 | |
| | UNION 55, Ithaca 41 | |
| | WABASH 38, Albion 20 | |
| | WESLEY 59, Ferrum 14 | |
| | WISCONSIN-WHITEWATER 34, Central 14 | |
| |
| Second Round | |
| November 26 | |
| | Bridgewater 24, THIEL 13 | |
| | Capital 14, WABASH 11 | |
| | DELAWARE VALLEY 21, Hobart 14 | |
| | LINFIELD 28, Concordia-Moorhead 14 | |
| | MOUNT UNION 44, Augustana 7 | |
| | Rowan 28, UNION 24 | |
| | Wesley 46, MARY HARDIN-BAYLOR 36 | |
| | WISCONSIN-WHITEWATER 34, St. John's 7 | |
| |
| Quarterfinals | |
| December 3 | |
| | MOUNT UNION 34, Capital 31 | |
| | Rowan 27, DELAWARE VALLEY 21 | |
| | WESLEY 46, Bridgewater 7 | |
| | Wisconsin-Whitewater 44, LINFIELD 41 | |
| |
| Semifinals | |
| December 10 | |
| | MOUNT UNION 19, Rowan 7 | |
| | WISCONSIN-WHITEWATER 58, Wesley 6 | |
| |
| Stagg Bowl | |
| December 17 | |
| | Mount Union 35, Wisconsin-Whitewater 28 (in Salem, Virginia) | |
| |
 |
| 2006 | |
| |
| First Round | |
| November 18 | |
| | CAPITAL 32, Wittenberg 14 | |
| | CARNEGIE MELLON 21, Millsaps 0 | |
| | MARY HARDIN-BAYLOR 33, Hardin-Simmons 21 | |
| | MOUNT UNION 49, Hope 0 | |
| | North Central 35, Concordia (WI) 6 (in Milwaukee, Wisconsin) | |
| | ROWAN 20, Hobart 18 | |
| | SPRINGFIELD 42, Curry 14 | |
| | ST. JOHN FISHER 49, Union 21 | |
| | St. John's 21, CENTRAL 13 | |
| | Washington and Jefferson 27, CHRISTOPHER NEWPORT 23 | |
| | WESLEY 49, Dickinson 21 | |
| | WHEATON 42, Mount St. Joseph 28 | |
| | WHITWORTH 27, Occidental 23 | |
| | WILKES 42, Washington and Lee 0 | |
| | WISCONSIN-LA CROSSE 28, Bethel 21 | |
| | WISCONSIN-WHITEWATER 59, St. Norbert 17 | |
| |
| Second Round | |
| November 25 | |
| | CAPITAL 41, North Central 13 | |
| | MARY HARDIN-BAYLOR 30, Washington and Jefferson 27 | |
| | MOUNT UNION 35, Wheaton 3 | |
| | Rowan 21, WILKES 14 | |
| | St. John Fisher 27, SPRINGFIELD 21 | |
| | St. John's 21, WHITWORTH 3 | |
| | WESLEY 37, Carnegie Mellon 0 | |
| | WISCONSIN-WHITEWATER 24, Wisconsin-La Crosse 21 | |
| |
| Quarterfinals | |
| December 2 | |
| | MOUNT UNION 17, Capital 14 | |
| | ST. JOHN FISHER 31, Rowan 0 | |
| | WESLEY 34, Mary Hardin-Baylor 20 | |
| | WISCONSIN-WHITEWATER 17, St. John's 14 | |
| |
| Semifinals | |
| December 9 | |
| | MOUNT UNION 26, St. John Fisher 14 | |
| | WISCONSIN-WHITEWATER 44, Wesley 7 | |
| |
| Stagg Bowl | |
| December 16 | |
| | Mount Union 35, Wisconsin-Whitewater 16 (in Salem, Virginia) | |
| |
 |
| 2007 | |
| |
| First Round | |
| November 17 | |
| | BETHEL 28, Concordia (WI) 0 | |
| | CASE WESTERN RESERVE 21, Widener 20 | |
| | CENTRAL 38, Olivet 17 | |
| | College of New Jersey 17, RENSSELAER 14 | |
| | CURRY 42, Hartwick 21 | |
| | MARY HARDIN-BAYLOR 52, Trinity (TX) 23 | |
| | MOUNT UNION 42, Ithaca 18 | |
| | MUHLENBERG 31, Salisbury 21 | |
| | North Carolina Wesleyan 35, WASHINGTON AND JEFFERSON 34 (ot) | |
| | North Central 44, FRANKLIN 42 | |
| | ST. JOHN FISHER 24, Hobart 7 | |
| | ST. JOHN'S 41, Redlands 13 | |
| | WABASH 31, Mount St. Joseph 21 | |
| | WESLEY 45, Hampden-Sydney 17 | |
| | Wisconsin-Eau Claire 24, ST. NORBERT 20 | |
| | WISCONSIN-WHITEWATER 34, Capital 14 | |
| |
| Second Round | |
| November 24 | |
| | BETHEL 21, Wisconsin-Eau Claire 12 | |
| | CENTRAL 37, St. John's 7 | |
| | MARY HARDIN-BAYLOR 64, North Carolina Wesleyan 0 | |
| | MOUNT UNION 59, College of New Jersey 7 | |
| | ST. JOHN FISHER 38, Curry 7 | |
| | Wabash 38, CASE WESTERN RESERVE 23 | |
| | WESLEY 38, Muhlenberg 21 | |
| | WISCONSIN-WHITEWATER 59, North Central 28 | |
| |
| Quarterfinals | |
| December 1 | |
| | Bethel 27, CENTRAL 7 | |
| | Mary Hardin-Baylor 27, WESLEY 10 | |
| | MOUNT UNION 52, St. John Fisher 10 | |
| | WISCONSIN-WHITEWATER 47, Wabash 7 | |
| |
| Semifinals | |
| December 8 | |
| | MOUNT UNION 62, Bethel 14 | |
| | WISCONSIN-WHITEWATER 16, Mary Hardin-Baylor 7 | |
| |
| Stagg Bowl | |
| December 15 | |
| | Wisconsin-Whitewater 31, Mount Union 21 (in Salem, Virginia) | |
| |
 |
| 2008 | |
| |
| First Round | |
| November 22 | |
| | CORTLAND 31, Plymouth State 14 | |
| | Curry 26, ITHACA 21 | |
| | Franklin 62, OTTERBEIN 45 | |
| | HOBART 33, Lycoming 15 | |
| | MARY HARDIN-BAYLOR 38, Hardin-Simmons 35 | |
| | MILLSAPS 51, LaGrange 26 | |
| | MONMOUTH 42, Aurora 13 | |
| | MOUNT UNION 56, Randolph-Macon 0 | |
| | NORTH CENTRAL 44, Thomas More 23 | |
| | Wabash 20, CASE WESTERN RESERVE 17 | |
| | Wartburg 26, WISCONSIN-STEVENS POINT 21 | |
| | WASHINGTON AND JEFFERSON 35, Christopher Newport 29 | |
| | Wesley 20, MUHLENBERG 0 | |
| | Wheaton 14, TRINE 0 | |
| | WILLAMETTE 48, Occidental 33 | |
| | WISCONSIN-WHITEWATER 37, St. John's 7 | |
| |
| Second Round | |
| November 29 | |
| | CORTLAND 42, Curry 0 | |
| | Franklin 38, NORTH CENTRAL 28 | |
| | MARY HARDIN-BAYLOR 46, Wesley 14 | |
| | MOUNT UNION 42, Hobart 7 | |
| | Wartburg 30, MONMOUTH 28 | |
| | Washington and Jefferson 35, MILLSAPS 20 | |
| | Wheaton 59, WABASH 28 | |
| | Wisconsin-Whitewater 30, WILLAMETTE 27 | |
| |
| Quarterfinals | |
| December 6 | |
| | MARY HARDIN-BAYLOR 63, Washington and Jefferson 7 | |
| | MOUNT UNION 41, Cortland 14 | |
| | Wheaton 45, FRANKLIN 28 | |
| | WISCONSIN-WHITEWATER 34, Wartburg 17 | |
| |
| Semifinals | |
| December 13 | |
| | MOUNT UNION 45, Wheaton 24 | |
| | Wisconsin-Whitewater 39, MARY HARDIN-BAYLOR 13 | |
| |
| Stagg Bowl | |
| December 20 | |
| | Mount Union 31, Wisconsin-Whitewater 26 (in Salem, Virginia) | |
| |
 |
| 2009 | |
| |
| First Round | |
| November 21 | |
| | Albright 35, ALFRED 25 | |
| | Coe 34, ST. JOHN'S 27 | |
| | DELAWARE VALLEY 66, Susquehanna 7 | |
| | ILLINOIS WESLEYAN 41, Wabash 35 (ot) | |
| | Johns Hopkins 23, HAMPDEN-SYDNEY 7 | |
| | LINFIELD 38, California Lutheran 17 | |
| | Mary Hardin-Baylor 42, CENTRAL 40 | |
| | Mississippi College 56, HUNTINGDON 35 | |
| | MONTCLAIR STATE 38, Maine Maritime 22 | |
| | MOUNT UNION 55, Washington and Jefferson 0 | |
| | St. Thomas 43, MONMOUTH 21 | |
| | THOMAS MORE 49, DePauw 39 | |
| | Trine 51, CASE WESTERN RESERVE 38 | |
| | WESLEY 55, North Carolina Wesleyan 23 | |
| | WISCONSIN-WHITEWATER 70, Lakeland 7 | |
| | WITTENBERG 42, Mount St. Joseph 14 | |
| |
| Second Round | |
| November 28 | |
| | Albright 27, DELAWARE VALLEY 3 | |
| | Johns Hopkins 31, THOMAS MORE 29 | |
| | LINFIELD 53, Mary Hardin-Baylor 21 | |
| | MOUNT UNION 62, Montclair State 14 | |
| | ST. THOMAS 34, Coe 7 | |
| | WESLEY 43, Mississippi College 9 | |
| | WISCONSIN-WHITEWATER 45, Illinois Wesleyan 7 | |
| | WITTENBERG 34, Trine 17 | |
| |
| Quarterfinals | |
| December 5 | |
| | LINFIELD 31, St. Thomas 20 | |
| | MOUNT UNION 55, Albright 3 | |
| | WESLEY 12, Johns Hopkins 0 | |
| | WISCONSIN-WHITEWATER 31, Wittenberg 13 | |
| |
| Semifinals | |
| December 12 | |
| | MOUNT UNION 24, Wesley 7 | |
| | WISCONSIN-WHITEWATER 27, Linfield 17 | |
| |
| Stagg Bowl | |
| December 19 | |
| | Wisconsin-Whitewater 38, Mount Union 28 (in Salem, Virginia) | |
| |
 |