Return Last Year: 2005
Trophy: Presented to Coast Guard by Allan Colvin, an RPI alum living in Connecticut, and was purloined from a Troy hotel during his reunion in 1944 to show how small the drinks were. Admiral James Pim, then the superintendent of the academy, remarked that it should be awarded to the winner each year. NOTE: Story related in Rensselaer Polytechnic issue of November 16, 1949.
Sites: '86 Field, Troy (except 1975 and 1977), Varsity Field, Troy (1975 and 1977); Jones Field, New London (1944-1970), Cadet Memorial Field, New London (since 1972, except 1980), St. Bernard High School Field, Uncasville (1980). NOTE: Jones Field and Cadet Memorial Field are the same field.
Rensselaer Record: 19-33-2
| Year | Date | Outcome | Location |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1944 | Oct. 14 | Coast Guard 38-6 | New London |
| 1945 | Oct. 13 | Rensselaer 18-7 | Troy |
| 1946 | Sep. 28 | Coast Guard 33-0 | New London |
| 1947 | Sep. 27 | Tie 19-19 | Troy |
| 1948 | Nov. 13 | Coast Guard 13-6 | New London |
| 1949 | Nov. 12 | Rensselaer 20-0 | Troy |
| 1950 | Nov. 11 | Coast Guard 27-0 | New London |
| 1951 | Nov. 10 | Coast Guard 35-14 | Troy |
| 1952 | Nov. 8 | Coast Guard 49-12 | New London |
| 1953 | Nov. 7 | Coast Guard 12-6 | Troy |
| 1954 | Nov. 6 | Coast Guard 35-7 | New London |
| 1955 | Nov. 5 | Coast Guard 13-0 | Troy |
| 1956 | Nov. 10 | Coast Guard 32-0 | New London |
| 1957 | Nov. 9 | Coast Guard 27-20 | Troy |
| 1958 | Nov. 8 | Coast Guard 28-8 | New London |
| 1959 | Nov. 7 | Coast Guard 19-2 | Troy |
| 1960 | Nov. 5 | Coast Guard 46-6 | New London |
| 1961 | Nov. 11 | Coast Guard 13-0 | Troy |
| 1968 | Nov. 16 | Coast Guard 34-20 | New London |
| 1970 | Sep. 19 | Coast Guard 31-3 | New London |
| 1971 | Sep. 18 | Coast Guard 28-27 | Troy |
| 1972 | Sep. 23 | Coast Guard 24-7 | New London |
| 1973 | Sep. 22 | Coast Guard 30-0 | Troy |
| 1974 | Sep. 21 | Coast Guard 3-0 | New London |
| 1975 | Sep. 20 | Coast Guard 26-22 | Troy |
| 1976 | Sep. 18 | Coast Guard 17-0 | New London |
| 1977 | Sep. 17 | Coast Guard 29-15 | Troy |
| 1978 | Sep. 16 | Coast Guard 29-0 | New London |
| 1979 | Sep. 15 | Tie 6-6 | Troy |
| 1980 | Sep. 13 | Rensselaer 12-7 | Uncasville |
| 1981 | Sep. 19 | Rensselaer 21-0 | Troy |
| 1982 | Sep. 18 | Rensselaer 24-22 | New London |
| 1983 | Sep. 17 | Rensselaer 14-7 | Troy |
| 1984 | Sep. 15 | Coast Guard 24-6 | New London |
| 1985 | Sep. 14 | Coast Guard 22-9 | Troy |
| 1986 | Sep. 13 | Coast Guard 16-9 | New London |
| 1987 | Sep. 19 | Coast Guard 7-3 | Troy |
| 1988 | Sep. 17 | Rensselaer 14-0 | New London |
| 1989 | Sep. 16 | Coast Guard 14-10 | Troy |
| 1990 | Sep. 15 | Rensselaer 7-6 | New London |
| 1991 | Sep. 14 | Coast Guard 14-7 | Troy |
| 1992 | Sep. 19 | Rensselaer 14-12 | New London |
| 1993 | Sep. 18 | Rensselaer 53-14 | Troy |
| 1994 | Sep. 17 | Rensselaer 28-17 | New London |
| 1995 | Sep. 16 | Rensselaer 21-20 | Troy |
| 1996 | Sep. 14 | Rensselaer 38-34 | New London |
| 1997 | Sep. 13 | Coast Guard 22-16 (ot) | Troy |
| 1998 | Sep. 19 | Rensselaer 45-16 | New London |
| 1999 | Sep. 18 | Rensselaer 42-3 | Troy |
| 2000 | Sep. 16 | Coast Guard 24-21 | New London |
| 2002 | Sep. 21 | Rensselaer 34-12 | New London |
| 2003 | Sep. 20 | Rensselaer 44-7 | Troy |
| 2004 | Oct. 2 | Rensselaer 28-17 | Troy |
| 2005 | Oct. 1 | Rensselaer 17-3 | New London |