Return Trophy: After the 1979 contest it was decided by the athletic directors of both schools to create a trophy for this long-standing rivalry. A transit was chosen since both schools are engineering schools.
Sites: '86 Field, Troy; Alumni Field, Worcester
Rensselaer Record: 19-8-1
| Year | Date | Outcome | Location |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1980 | Oct. 25 | Rensselaer 30-13 | Troy |
| 1981 | Oct. 31 | WPI 27-14 | Worcester |
| 1982 | Oct. 30 | Rensselaer 7-3 | Troy |
| 1983 | Oct. 29 | WPI 28-8 | Worcester |
| 1984 | Oct. 27 | Rensselaer 10-7 | Troy |
| 1985 | Oct. 26 | WPI 28-21 | Worcester |
| 1986 | Oct. 25 | Rensselaer 28-24 | Troy |
| 1987 | Oct. 31 | Rensselaer 23-21 | Worcester |
| 1988 | Oct. 1 | Rensselaer 26-7 | Troy |
| 1989 | Sep. 30 | WPI 31-24 | Worcester |
| 1990 | Sep. 29 | Tie 17-17 | Troy |
| 1991 | Sep. 28 | WPI 26-14 | Worcester |
| 1992 | Oct. 3 | WPI 28-14 | Troy |
| 1993 | Oct. 2 | Rensselaer 31-14 | Worcester |
| 1994 | Oct. 1 | Rensselaer 21-14 | Troy |
| 1995 | Sep. 30 | WPI 21-20 | Worcester |
| 1996 | Oct. 5 | WPI 13-10 | Troy |
| 1997 | Oct. 4 | Rensselaer 37-16 | Worcester |
| 1998 | Sep. 26 | Rensselaer 42-19 | Troy |
| 1999 | Sep. 25 | Rensselaer 42-27 | Worcester |
| 2000 | Sep. 23 | Rensselaer 45-0 | Troy |
| 2001 | Sep. 22 | Rensselaer 31-14 | Worcester |
| 2002 | Sep. 28 | Rensselaer 33-13 | Troy |
| 2003 | Sep. 27 | Rensselaer 34-26 | Worcester |
| 2004 | Oct. 30 | Rensselaer 35-33 | Troy |
| 2005 | Oct. 29 | Rensselaer 31-15 | Worcester |
| 2006 | Oct. 28 | Rensselaer 26-0 | Troy |
| 2007 | Oct. 27 | Rensselaer 21-14 (ot) | Worcester |